- Pope Francis: A nun saved my life
- Israeli P.M. Netanyahu backs out of Mandela funeral
- Elian Gonzalez makes first trip outside Cuba since custody battle
- U.S., British intelligence agents enter online sci-fi world to spy on gamers
- Sarah Palin to host the outdoors show ‘Amazing America’
- CIA admits $3 billion intelligence operation was a flop
- ‘127 Hours’ author Aron Lee Ralston, who amputated arm in canyon, arrested in Denver
- Men posing as cops break into home of former deputy
- Berkshire County eschews greenback for own currency — BerkShares
- Hagel warns Pakistani leaders of U.S. aid losses over drone-strike protests
Judge’s role in plea overturns sentence
A federal appeals court overturned a prison sentence of more than four years given to a local investment consultant on money-laundering charges, saying the judge in the case was improperly involved in plea talks.
A ruling last week by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit gives Kenneth C. Baker, 44, the right to a new trial on charges he schemed to steal an 88-year-old woman’s life savings last year.
The appellate court’s ruling says that despite “good intentions,” U.S. District Court Judge Emmett G. Sullivan committed an error in Baker’s case that “reflects badly on the fundamental fairness of the judicial process.”
At issue were statements made by Judge Sullivan in March 2006 after he requested an update on plea talks between prosecutors and Baker’s defense attorney.
Prosecutors told the judge that they were offering 21 to 27 months if Baker, a former SunTrust Bank employee, pleaded guilty to bilking his client of her $96,000 life savings.
At that point, court records show, Judge Sullivan said he accepted a guilty plea months earlier from a 63-year-old man who embezzled about $100,000 from an employee pension plan.
Judge Sullivan said he had sentenced the man to one year and one day in prison and noted that “judges do try to be consistent.”
“I would probably be just as consistent here,” said Judge Sullivan. “I’m not going to do one thing in one case where the facts are similar and do something completely different here. I’m just not going to do it. I’m going to be consistent to the extent I can.”
The rules of federal criminal procedure prohibit “all forms of judicial participation in or interference with the plea negotiation process.”
The next day, Baker pleaded guilty. Four months later, at his sentencing in July, Baker explained his motivation to the judge.
“When I came in here on March 2 and fell on my sword, I was pretty much thinking in relation to a case that you had referenced prior to my making my guilty plea of an individual who, I think you said, he took a hundred and some odd thousand dollars and you gave him like a year and a day,” Baker said.
Judge Sullivan sentenced Baker to 41 months in prison for federal charges followed by another 10 months on D.C.-related charges. The 51-month sentence was nearly twice the maximum sentence the government was offering for a guilty plea.
Baker appealed the sentence, arguing that Judge Sullivan violated his rights by improperly taking part in plea talks.
In an 18-page opinion written by Judge Janice Rogers Brown — a 2005 appointee of President Bush — the appeals court agreed, concluding that Judge Sullivan “unilaterally initiated and engaged in a lengthy plea discussion with Baker.”
Prosecutors argued that Judge Sullivan, appointed to the federal bench in 1994 by President Clinton, later repeatedly said during the plea hearing that no promises were made.
By Brahma Chellaney
Beijing's creeping aggression signals a challenge to U.S. presence in the Asian Pacific
- CURL: Obama tells a whopper on IRS scandal
- WOLF: The president's other Obamacare lies
- Tech companies call for an end to NSA online snooping
- Lawmakers see 'false narrative' of Obama as a terrorist fighter
- Satanists petition for statue at Oklahoma Statehouse
- Obama lied about Syrian chemical attack, 'cherry-picked' intelligence: report
- Ted Cruz sees legal landmines ahead for Obamacare
- MSNBC host: Obamacare a 'wealthy white men' racist word
- WWII vet, 90, en route to Pearl Harbor event booted from flight
- U.S. pilot scares off Iranians with 'Top Gun'-worthy stunt: 'You really ought to go home'
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Brazen, leading-edge, “call it like it is” columns and reporting from Ohio native, radio host and writer, Sara Marie Brenner.
Let’s talk about everything, especially the absurdity of it all
Find the latest news and happening that effect those in the Washington D.C., Northern Virginia and Maryland Metro region.
Never apologetic. Never afraid. Lieutenant Colonel Allen B. West joins Communities to bring tales from the biggest Foxhole of them all, the one inside the Beltway.
White House pets gone wild!
Let it snow