- Judge strikes down Arkansas abortion law — nation’s toughest — as unconstitutional
- Court: Tenn. must recognize 3 same-sex marriages
- Russia claims to have downed U.S. drone over Crimea region
- John Daly shoots 90 at PGA Tour event: ‘I’m falling apart’
- Police: Man arrested in West Virginia may be linked to Alexandria killings
- Smile: Equipping cops with body-mounted cameras gains steam in Calif., N.Y.
- Obama to sign bill cutting taxpayer money for party conventions
- Half of Americans worried about second Cold War: poll
- Kermit Gosnell clinic aide who heard aborted baby scream gets 5 to 10 years in prison
- Iraq mulls law to let men marry 8-year-old girls
Obama aide tied to failed immigration program
One of President-elect Barack Obama’s top immigration advisers oversaw a Clinton-era program that awarded U.S. citizenship to thousands of convicted criminals and failed to conduct adequate FBI background checks on foreigners during a push to reduce a backlog of naturalization applications.
T. Alexander Aleinikoff, former executive associate commissioner for programs at the now-defunct Immigration and Naturalization Service, staunchly defended the program, Citizenship USA (CUSA), before Congress a decade ago, although the Justice Department’s Office of Inspector General concluded in 2000 that the program failed to address weaknesses that pushed the immigration system beyond its limits.
CUSA saw 1.2 million foreign nationals become U.S. citizens in 1996. Many of them later were identified as convicted criminals. The program was endorsed vigorously by President Clinton but attacked by critics as an election-year ploy to speed naturalizations for political gain, noting that the program targeted INS districts in heavily Democratic Chicago, Los Angeles, Miami, New York City and San Francisco.
More than 180,000 naturalization applications were vetted without proper FBI fingerprint analyses, including 80,000 immigrants who had fingerprint checks that generated criminal records but were naturalized anyway, according to congressional and federal investigators.
The inspector general’s report said applicants who were ineligible because of criminal records or because they fraudulently obtained green cards were granted citizenship because the INS was “moving too fast to check their records.”
Mr. Aleinikoff, now dean and executive vice president at Georgetown University School of Law, did not return telephone messages for comment left for him this week and last. He and Mariano-Florentino “Tino” Cuellar, a professor at Stanford Law School and a senior Treasury Department adviser in the Clinton administration, were named last month by Mr. Obama to co-lead his immigration policy transition team.
Mr. Obama’s transition team did not immediately return an e-mail on Monday asking for comment.
According to the inspector general’s 684-page report, CUSA failed to address national security concerns, did not develop or coordinate anti-fraud operations, and failed to ensure that foreign nationals seeking naturalization underwent law-enforcement background checks.
The report said it was “widely known” among INS officials in Washington that thousands of foreign nationals with criminal records were allowed to become U.S. citizens. It said INS compromised the integrity of the naturalization system as a result of “its efforts to process applicants more quickly and meet a self-imposed goal of completing more than a million cases by the end of fiscal 1996.”
It was estimated at the time that INS failed to complete FBI background checks for nearly 20 percent of those naturalized under CUSA.
In testimony before a Senate subcommittee in 1996, Mr. Aleinikoff praised CUSA for reducing processing times for citizenship applications nationwide “while maintaining the integrity of the citizenship process.” He testified that CUSA handled applications for naturalization “in a timely, accurate and responsible manner.”
But acting Inspector General Robert L. Ashbaugh said at the time that given CUSA’s deficiencies, INS had put “any hope for integrity in the adjudication of citizenship at great risk” in an effort to process massive numbers of pending cases.
“INS leadership took no serious steps before implementing CUSA to protect the naturalization process from further degradation,” Mr. Ashbaugh said. “Instead, they added highly unrealistic production quotas which overtaxed the system and led to further diminution of naturalization quality.
“INS failed to address known system weaknesses before implementing a program it knew would tax that system as it never had been taxed before,” he said.
A Government Accountability Office (GAO) report at the time also warned that CUSA had significant loopholes, including the fact that INS was able to accept fingerprints handed in by the applicants themselves instead of performing them in its offices. As a result, the GAO said, immigrants with criminal records could cheat the system easily by switching someone else’s fingerprints in place of their own.
About the Author
Jerry Seper is the investigative editor for The Washington Times.
- With bombs away, drug traffickers and illegal immigrants make their play
- Medical-device company exec admits to bilking shareholders of $400M
- Justice Dept: Florida's disabled children unnecessarily put in nursing facilities
- Man gets 11 years in Philadelphia mob crackdown
- Eric Holder asks for respect from protesters of George Zimmerman verdict
Latest Blog Entries
By David A. Clarke Jr.
Blame Washington's intelligence failure, not lack of police
- EDITORIAL: Lois Lerner's dilemma
- EXCLUSIVE: FBI blocked in corruption probe involving Sens. Reid, Lee
- Russia claims to have downed U.S. drone over Crimea region
- Bill Clinton struggled to address Islamic extremism: documents
- College group's diversity event canceled after excluding white people
- USS Kidd sent to Indian Ocean after 'indication' of Malaysian jet crash
- Trust me: Obama promises new overtime rules will be 'easier for everyone'
- BRUCE: The power of bossy
- Sam Adams beer brewer nixes St. Patrick's parade that won't allow gays
- BIRNBAUM: Congress will have a busy 2014
Chaos as Manhattan building explodes
Pope Francis meets his 'mini-me'
Celebrity deaths in 2014