Inside Blogotics

By Victor Morton (Contact) | Tuesday, July 1, 2008

• Print
• [-][+] Font Size
• E-Mail Alerts
• Tell a Friend
• Got a Question?
• You Report
• Click-2-Listen

Liberal vs. liberal

In the blue corner: Glenn Greenwald of Salon. In the red corner: Keith Olbermann of MSNBC and DailyKos. The issue: Sen. Barack Obama's reversal of his opposition to a bill to update the 30-year-old Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), which largely grants the administration what it wants on the hot-button issue of immunity for telecommunications firms.

At his Salon blog Unclaimed Territory, Mr. Greenwald noted Mr. Olbermann's having called the provision a "literally textbook example of Fascism" being pushed by "the bureaucrats of the Third Reich." Then he crammed down Mr. Olbermann's throat an MSNBC transcript in which the host praised the Obama vote as "not cowering to the left, not going along with ... the new conventional thinking on the FISA bill."

"What's much more notable is Olbermann's full-scale reversal on how he talks about these measures now that Obama - rather than George Bush - supports them," Mr. Greenwald notes. "Grave warning on Olbermann's show that telecom amnesty and FISA revisions were hallmarks of Bush Fascism instantaneously transformed into a celebration that Obama, by supporting the same things, was leading a courageous, centrist crusade in defense of our Constitution."

In a pungent response in his DailyKos diary, Mr. Olbermann said he had changed his mind about the poisonous nature of the FISA bill after talking to John Dean, whom he said had told him that it would only grant the companies civil immunity, but they still could be criminally prosecuted.

Mr. Olbermann said he hoped Mr. Obama's strategy was to "shut up and take the criticism and hope the Republicans don't see the loophole," though a cynic might question the wisdom of saying this publicly at one of the most widely read sites on the Internet. He then went on to the kidney punches ("I don't know much about Mr. Greenwald and I didn't read his full piece") and the rabbit punches (his "suggestion of some kind of betrayal on my part is simplistic and childish.")

Mr. Greenwald fired back the next day, criticizing both Mr. Olbermann's rationalization (noting the skepticism of both Mr. Dean and "Kos" himself Markos Moulitsas) and also the mentality he said it reflected (throwing the lowest liberal blow: a comparison to President Bush).

"There are likely many reasons for [the bill to confine] immunity to civil liability - including the heightened difficulty of proving criminal intent and, most importantly, the fact that Bush, on his way out, can pardon telecoms from criminal but not civil liability. So it's far from certain that Obama - even if he did have a Secret Plan criminally to prosecute telecoms once in office - would even be able to do so," he noted.

"To give Obama a pass on his support for such a heinous bill ... based on this imagined secret plan for the Good that Obama is harboring is to illustrate exactly the sort of blind faith in political leaders that is so dangerous. That's been the Right's mentality to excuse every last thing Bush does."

L'Electrique slide

Click here for reprint permissions!
Copyright 2009 The Washington Times, LLC

Do you have another point of view, photos, audio, video or more information about a story?