Register for E-mail alerts. Comment on articles. Sign up today, it's easy.
Close
The Washington Times Online Edition

‘Relevant conduct’ can add to sentences

Steven Kalar, senior litigator in the Northern District of California’s Office of Federal Public Defender, tells his clients facing big conspiracy cases to keep in mind the movie “Raiders of the Lost Ark.”

“If you get hit, and it doesn’t matter if it’s even with one little dart, you’re dead,” Mr. Kalar said. “They’re going to argue relevant conduct.”

The point, he said, is that a criminal defendant might not benefit greatly from acquittal of all the charges in a major conspiracy case except for a seemingly minor count.

Prosecutors still can point to “relevant conduct” - the acquitted charges that jurors rejected or other accusations the jury never heard - and ask a judge to mete out a tougher sentence.

Mr. Kalar said that while juries must make their findings based beyond a reasonable doubt, sentencing judges instead can base their findings on a preponderance of evidence.

“I do think the Supreme Court will be addressing the issue very soon,” he said.

James Bilsborrow, who recently published an article on acquitted conduct sentencing in the William & Mary Law Review, said the consideration of acquitted or uncharged conduct at sentencing is a recent phenomenon.

“In the past, you could get sentencing enhancements, but nothing that would take you up to 40 years,” said Mr. Bilsborrow, who reviewed the defense and prosecution memos in the D.C. federal court case of Antwuan Ball.

Ball was acquitted on murder and racketeering charges but convicted of one $600 drug deal. Defense attorneys say sentencing guidelines show Ball, who has a 1995 weapons conviction, should be released within a few years.

In memos, prosecutors say Ball deserves the 40 years, the maximum allowed by law for his drug charge, because he has intimidated witnesses, lied in court testimony and remains a danger to the community.

Defense attorneys balk at the description. They say it’s unfair to ask for 40 years when jurors only found Ball guilty of a single drug transaction, acquitting him of the more serious charges

On Friday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia noted the debate over the sentencing issue in the case of Tarik Settles, who had appealed his 57-month sentence on a firearms conviction.

“To be sure, we understand why defendants find it unfair for district courts to rely on acquitted conduct when imposing a sentence,” the judges concluded in their opinion.

“For those reasons, Congress or the Sentencing Commission certainly could conclude as a policy matter that sentencing courts may not rely on acquitted conduct. But under binding precedent, the Constitution does not prohibit a sentencing court from relying on acquitted conduct.”

Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like
  • Delegate Robert G. Marshall holds a book as he reads to the House during debate on a bill defining life at the moment of conception during the House session at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Monday, Feb. 13, 2012.  (AP Photo/Steve Helber)

    Virginia House vote states life starts at conception

    By David Sherfinski - The Washington Times

  • A bomb specialist examines debris Tuesday in Bangkok where two explosions rocked a neighborhood. An Iranian man injured by a grenade he was carrying also was linked to a blast that ripped part of a roof off a house. (Associated Press)

    U.S. concerned about spike in Iran-Israel ‘shadow war’

    By Guy Taylor - The Washington Times

  • Mabus

    Naming of Navy ships returns to tradition

    By Rowan Scarborough - The Washington Times

  • In Case You Missed It
    Happening Now

          Independent voices from the TWT Communities

          The Tygrrrr Express

          A politically conservative and morally liberal Hebrew alpha male hunts left-wing vipers.

          Alley-Oops

          Immerse yourselves in the genius insights of a high school sports freak and statistical wizard who knows it all. Or at least thinks he does.