EDGE: The Richard Dawkins delusion

• Article
• Comments ()
• Click-2-Listen
• Videos

By Scott Galupo

Richard Dawkins, the evolutionary biologist and "God Delusion" polemicist, recently offered a frightening glimpse of what might be called the reverse-fundamentalist worldview.

Mr. Dawkins mused to a British television network that fairy tales and supernatural-themed books such as the "Harry Potter" series are "anti-scientific."

"Whether that has a pernicious effect, I don't know," the 67-year-old British writer said. "Looking back to my own childhood, the fact that so many of the stories I read allowed the possibility of frogs turning into princes, whether that has a sort of insidious effect on rationality, I'm not sure. Perhaps it's something for research."

It's telling that, in this case, the conclusion, provisional though it may be, reached by a hyperrationalist scientist mirrors exactly that of those who object to "Harry Potter" on religious grounds: that a mind that too frequently wanders from the realm of settled truth becomes vulnerable to poisonous falsehoods.

Mr. Dawkins' suspicion of fairy tales - of imagination - is an indication of the extremes to which philosophical materialism can lead.

Here's a guy, after all, who confesses to having read "so many" "anti-scientific" stories. Yet he grew to become one of the most eminent popular-science writers of his time - not unlike, one presumes, any number of scientists who, as adolescents, graduated into the fantastical realm of fiction writers such as J.R.R. Tolkein and Isaac Asimov.

Why the hand-wringing?

Mr. Dawkins has a grown daughter. I wonder how well he recalls her storybook years.

If she was anything like the 4-year-old I observe daily, Mr. Dawkins must have noticed that the still-forming toddler's mind is as open to the natural world as it is willing to believe that frogs turn into princes. It inquires about stars in the night sky as hungrily as it grapples with the concept of "heaven."

As we grow older, many of us, sadly, lose interest in math and science. During the same time, we outgrow fairy tales. There is, I believe, a connection there.