- Israel mulls gift of West Bank land to Palestinians
- Stocks gain as investors weigh economic news
- Doctors say ‘profound’ new HIV treatment may prove the cure
- Mexican truck with radioactive load stolen
- NYPD head Ray Kelly wins big retirement perk — a $1.5M tax-paid team of bodyguards
- #smh: Pentagon may forgive recruits’ vulgar, disrespectful social media posts
- Libraries to feds: Stop spying on us
- Britain eyes new powers to thwart Islamic extremists
- Angry NTSB ousts railroad union from N.Y. train crash site
- Sen. Bernie Sanders hints at White House run
THOMAS: Catholics divided over abortion (again)
Question of the Day
In recent elections when a high-profile Roman Catholic Democrat seeks high, or higher office, the issue of abortion surfaces. As the pro-choice, non-Catholic Barack Obama makes a play for evangelical voters, conservative Catholics are asking their fellow believers to take seriously the church’s teaching on abortion and not cast their vote for Mr. Obama and Catholic Joe Biden.
The split in Democratic ranks is along political as well as theological lines. Liberal Catholics claim government programs advocated by Democrats more accurately reflect the teachings of Jesus about the poor and the weak. More “observant” Catholics, some of whom support anti-poverty government programs, point out that no program can help someone who is not given the right to live. Liberals want Catholics to look beyond abortion. Would they have been comfortable 50 years ago with appeals for Catholics to look beyond the racism of Southern Democratic senators? Probably not.
A group calling itself Faithful Catholic Citizens” (FCC) has produced two powerful television commercials, which are running in Iowa and soon, it hopes, in heavily Catholic Pennsylvania. Both spots begin with a confrontational question: “Are you truly Catholic” and follow with a sound bite from “Meet the Press” in which Speaker Nancy Pelosi asserts that Catholic teaching on abortion has been inconsistent.
“Utterly incredible,” Cardinal Edward Egan is then quoted as saying about Mrs. Pelosi’s statement, which is followed by one from the late Pope John Paul II, who called abortion “[the] deliberate killing of an innocent human being.” And then comes a reference to Sen. Barack Obama from Rick Warren’s forum in August at which Mr. Obama said that knowing when life begins is “above my pay grade.”
“Don’t be misled,” continue the ads, “Know the church. Know the truth.” (View both ads at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ww7Rv_KjGDM.)
Is abortion “intrinsically evil” and “a non-negotiable issue for Catholics,” as Faithful Catholics President Heidi Stirrup asserts? If one is a Catholic and subscribes to the belief that the interpretation of Scripture and moral truth is the responsibility of the pope and the apostolic bishops, one would have to say, “yes”; and when faith and politics conflict, a politician should be required to choose one or the other.
Some Catholic politicians have tried to have it both ways. They have even tried to gain favor among fellow Catholics by noting their strong opposition to capital punishment, which puts them in an oddly inconsistent position. Such Catholic politicians favor preserving the lives of convicted murderers, but do nothing when they have the power to stop, or at least curtail, the killing of the innocent unborn.
While I am not a Catholic, it seems more than inconsistent to take such a position. One chooses one’s denomination, just as one chooses one’s political affiliation. No one forces another to become a Catholic and no one requires one to become a Democrat or Republican. Judicial nominees have been denied confirmation based on their membership in clubs that excluded blacks and Jews. But now we may be about to elevate two men to our highest offices who would deny civil rights to African-American babies (who are aborted disproportionately to other races), one of whom seeks the votes of his fellow Catholics.
Two years ago, Pope Benedict XVI reiterated the church’s “non-negotiable” issues: “Protection of life at all stages, from the moment of conception until natural death; recognition and promotion of the natural structure of the family as a union between a man and a woman based on marriage; the protection of the rights of parents to educate their children.”
Mr. Obama and Mr. Biden oppose at least two of these (they claim to be against same-sex “marriage,” but for “civil unions”). Whether the TV ads change any minds may be problematic. Catholics enamored with “change” and the belief that government is the primary instrument of God, rather than the church, in carrying out His will - and who have ignored church teaching on profound moral issues - are unlikely to be swayed by further appeals to become “truly Catholic.” But if only a few see where an Obama-Biden administration would take the country on moral issues, in a close election that might be enough.
Cal Thomas is a nationally syndicated columnist.
About the Author
By Tom Harris and Madhav Khandekar
Bad science puts rich nations on the hook for trillions in climate liabilities
- Hola: Boehner prepares to push amnesty bill through House
- U.S. drops 2,000 mice on Guam by parachute to kill snakes
- Kill team: Obama war chiefs widen drone death zones
- MILLER: Obamas EPA closing smelter will not affect ammunition supply
- Issa: FBI impeding inquiry into IRS targeting of conservative groups
- CARSON: Getting to the top by starting at the bottom
- Westboro Baptists slam actor Paul Walker: He's 'in Hell'
- Last call: State Dept. bought $180,000 in liquor before shutdown
- Apple wins facial recognition patent for iPhone 6
- Harry Reid gives some staffers a pass on Obamacare
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Columns from Voices around the World talking about the events, people, politics and social issues that concern us wherever, and whoever, we are.
This column will cover anything that has anything remotely to do with the game of baseball, from the game itself to mid-summer trades to offseason moves.
The cold hard truth about politics in America today and the state of this once great nation.
Never apologetic. Never afraid. Lieutenant Colonel Allen B. West joins Communities to bring tales from the biggest Foxhole of them all, the one inside the Beltway.