Home > News > Editor Favorites

U.S. incursions seen as risky for Pakistan

New government still fragile

By Sara A. Carter (Contact) | Sunday, September 28, 2008

Article
Comments ()

U.S. policy targeting al Qaeda militants inside Pakistan without its foreknowledge and consent may be jeopardizing the country's fragile democratic government, which is struggling to defeat Islamic extremists on its own, regional specialists and U.S. intelligence officials say.

A recent exchange of fire along the Afghan border between Pakistani and U.S. forces could be a sign of dissent within the Pakistani military about newly elected Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari's close relationship with Washington and with Afghan President Hamid Karzai, the officials and specialists said.

"Pakistan has experienced a period of serious political uncertainty over the past year," said a U.S. official, who is familiar with intelligence reporting on Pakistan and asked not to be identified because of the nature of his work.

"As the new government settles in, political opponents operating within the system - or opponents of the Pakistani political system itself, such as extremists operating out of the country´s tribal areas - may very well try to take advantage of that."

It's still not clear why the Pakistani military shot Thursday at two NATO helicopters, which International Security Assistance Forces (ISAF) said were not flying in Pakistan's airspace. There were also reports of an exchange of fire between ground forces, although no reports of casualties.

It's possible that the Pakistani military acted without authorization from civilian authorities to protest previous U.S. incursions into Pakistan, including a raid on Sept. 3.

Mr. Zardari was in New York at the time of the exchange of fire, attending the U.N. General Assembly.

"There is much suspicion between the army and Zardari," said Bruce Riedel, an expert in counterterrorism and senior adviser to three U.S. presidents. "He has little, if any, control of the army or ISI [Pakistan's intelligence service]."

Members of the Pakistani army and ISI are suspected of aiding al Qaeda and Taliban members.

Mr. Riedel added that Pakistani army officials may also be "suspicious of [Mr. Zardari's] close ties to Karzai."