- Obama military downsizing leaves U.S. too weak to counter global threats, panel finds
- Sen. Tom Coburn vows to slow down budget-busting bills ahead of recess
- Obama fantasizes about more executive power, signs new order on federal contractors
- Clintons call Klein, Halper, Kessler ‘a Hat Trick of despicable actors’: report
- Boehner accuses Obama of ‘legacy of lawlessness’
- Pro-marijuana group claims responsibility for Brooklyn Bridge flag swap
- Young adults shun Obamacare mostly due to cost: survey
- Stabbing attack on transgender girl, 15, was ‘bias motivated,’ police say
- LGBT adults still lean overwhelmingly toward Democratic Party
- Lawmakers rattled by Syria genocide horrors, call on Obama to act
‘Sexting’ is thorny legal issue
Question of the Day
The Vermont state Senate wasn’t planning to address what has become known as “sexting” this session when lawmakers held a hearing on a proposed expansion of state sex-offender laws.
But a mother testifying before the judiciary panel referred to the phenomenon, in which teens send suggestive videos or pictures of themselves to each other on cell phones.
“One of our witnesses said that her daughter had received this video, a depiction of somebody seminude, and said, ‘Wow, she didn’t want it, she didn’t ask for it’ — it’s actually a crime to possess child pornography,” said state Senate Judiciary Chairman Richard Sears, a Democrat who represents Bennington.
“It was all new to us, but the more we looked at it, the more we felt we needed to deal with it.”
Vermont is not alone. Lawmakers across the country face the dilemma of trying to discourage the activity while making a distinction between a youthful mistake and a criminal act of child pornography.
One in five teen girls nationwide has sent or posted a nude or seminude photo, according to a study by the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy. Fallout from the unintended spread of the pictures has been blamed for at least one death, when an 18-year-old Cincinnati high school student hanged herself last summer after her boyfriend circulated a nude cell-phone photo.
After some debate, lawmakers in Vermont decided to tweak state law so that minors caught sexting would not be charged with a felony and forced to register as sex offenders, so long as the incident was done voluntarily and without coercion. Instead, offenders could face misdemeanor charges in juvenile court.
“If somebody received it and they’re under 18, it would not be a violation as long as they made reasonable attempts to destroy or eliminate the visual depiction,” Mr. Sears said, stressing that the bill does not legalize the activity of sexting itself.
The measure is now law, and legislators in Utah and Ohio are pursuing a similar tack.
In some states, however, prosecutors have decided that filing criminal charges against teens who engage in sexting is the best means of prevention.
New Jersey police earlier this year arrested a 14-year-old girl for posting nude pictures of herself on a social-networking network. Prosecutors charged her with distribution of child pornography.
In Ohio, a 15-year-old girl agreed to a curfew, the loss of her cell phone and supervised Internet usage to avoid being charged with a felony.
In Pennsylvania, lawyers for the American Civil Liberties Union intervened on behalf of three teenage girls threatened with felony charges over suggestive cell-phone photos. The group is suing the district attorney for violating the girls’ First Amendment rights, arguing that the photos do not constitute child pornography.
Carolyn Atwell-Davis, director of legislative affairs at the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, cautioned against a “blanket approach” to laws that address sexting. Citing a case in Wisconsin in which a teenager attempted to blackmail other students after obtaining nude photos, she noted that not all instances of sexting are consensual.
“These cases are best handled on a case-by-case basis,” she said. “It’s all over the map, and you cannot deal with this in a general blanket fashion. Law enforcement and prosecutors need to have the flexibility to deal with this.”
About the Author
Kara Rowland, White House reporter for The Washington Times, is a D.C.-area native. She graduated from the University of Virginia, where she studied American government and spent nearly all her waking hours working as managing editor of the Cavalier Daily, UVa.’s student newspaper.
Her interest in political reporting was piqued by an internship at Roll Call the summer before her ...
- London Olympics not everyone's cup of tea
- Obama hits road to push jobs plan
- Obama calls for the end of 'political circus' on economy, seeks stimulus plan for jobs
- Brennan: Al Qaeda is 'organization in distress'
- Hoffa's words about labor's importance brushed off
Latest Blog Entries
TWT Video Picks
Both parties recognize the Democrats' scam
- Inside the Ring: Israel surprised by Hamas tunnel network
- Israel surprised by Hamas tunnel network
- Obama military strategy too weak for future security, panel reports
- CRUZ: A tale of two hospitals: One in Israel, one in Gaza
- Chicken pox outbreak puts illegal immigrant facility on lockdown
- EDITORIAL: For too many gays, 'tolerance' is a one-way street
- PRUDEN: Cooling the manufactured impeachment panic
- HUSAIN: Fleeing Iraqi Christians find safe haven at the Shrine of Imam Ali
- Feds accept boredom, lack of work as excuses for surfing porn on clock
- Catholic League slams Obama: 'Do Christian lives mean so little to you?'
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world