MMQB: Redskins get younger, but are they better?

Question of the Day

Is it still considered bad form to talk politics during a social gathering?

View results

By keeping 15 players who are in their first or second year, the Washington Redskins’ coaching staff continues to influence the roster by discarding the aging for younger and more durable parts who are capable of playing an entire season without spending Monday through Friday in the trainer’s room.

As they are presently constructed, the Redskins will be a younger team when they face the New York Giants on Sunday in the Swamp.

But will they be better?

Perhaps, but it might not result in a giant jump from last year’s 8-8 record because the Redskins play in the wrong division and face another tough December schedule (two West Coast trips, two NFC East home games).

Q: Who were the biggest surprises on the 53-man roster?

A: No question: offensive linemen D’Anthony Batiste and Edwin Williams.

Batiste made it as a reserve tackle after Jeremy Bridges proved what everyone thought all along: He’s a guard, not a tackle, and therefore expendable. Williams is the 10th offensive lineman after the former Maryland center showed he could also play both guard spots.

The Redskins are carrying an extra offensive lineman, but that doesn’t mean they’re not in trouble if one of the starters goes down. The career starts for the five reserves: Williams 0, Batiste 4, Chad Rinehart 0, Will Montgomery 6 and Mike Williams 48 (none since 2005).

Q: Speaking of Mike Williams, how did the Redskins justify his roster spot?

A: Front office boss Vinny Cerrato and coach Jim Zorn both praised Williams’ play against Jacksonville. But the fact he’s on the team borders on nonsense and comes from the theory that the Redskins want to pat themselves on the back for signing the reclamation project.

Withhold complete judgment until the big guy has to play 70 snaps in a game, but 2009 should be treated as a redshirt season for Williams, who can get used to practicing every day and then challenge for a position next training camp.

Q: What’s the theory on keeping an extra running back (Marcus Mason) and cornerback (Byron Westbrook)?

A: Although it’s a compliment to their play in the preseason, it’s also an indictment on what the Redskins think they have with the Ladell Betts-Rock Cartwright and Justin Tryon-Kevin Barnes combos at running back and cornerback, respectively.

Cerrato mentioned Mason’s role, including third-down work. That’s not good news for Betts, who worked almost exclusively in that situation during the preseason. The guess is that the coaches aren’t confident in Betts’ or, for that matter, Clinton Portis’ ability to get the tough yards at the goal line. Enter Mason, who is 5-foot-9 and 215 but has a bulldozer mentality.

Westbrook made the team with solid play and because of a stinker of a month from Tryon and Barnes, one of whom may find himself inactive Sunday at 4:15 p.m. This is a huge opportunity for Westbrook, who toiled for two years on the practice squad and now could work himself into nickel and dime packages.

Story Continues →

View Entire Story
Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus