- ‘I Am Alive’ app gains popularity in terror-ravaged Lebanon
- Gun giveaways gain popularity among Republican candidates
- S.C. hospital worker slapped with $525 federal fine for refilling $0.89 soda
- Teen from ‘Jihad Jane’ plot becomes youngest ever to serve time on U.S. terror charges
- Iranian woman forgives son’s killer at the gallows
- Nebraska principal sorry for ‘don’t tattle’ flier
- Illinois readies to spend $100M for Obama museum in Chicago
- John Edwards back in court — this time as a lawyer for Va. boy’s malpractice case
- Covered California reports more than 200K in overtime Obamacare sign-ups
- Thanks, Chuck: Hagel says U.S. sending Ukraine sleeping mats, helmets
LETTER TO EDITOR: Thinking like a libertarian
William H. Peterson quotes Adam Smith about the priority of consumption over production (“World peace through world trade,” Opinion, Monday), but Smith was dreadfully wrong. The desire to consume is a given and also limitless. Production determines whether these desires can be met. It is what separates a developed economy from an underdeveloped one.
Production must be the center of policy because it not only provides goods and services but also generates the income for those who work so they can become consumers (and savers). We have before us the ruins of an economy that has for a generation been based on consumption funded by debt rather than on income from production.
On the issue of peaceful trade, Mr. Peterson repeatedly cites the Cato Institute, which often quotes the early 19th century writings of Frederic Bastiat. Bastiat argued, “Free trade means harmony of interests and peace between nations.” His faith led him to say, “I shall not hesitate to vote for disarmament because I do not believe in invasions.” This was an untenable outlook for someone who lived in France, but it was common among classical economists.
Mr. Peterson also cites Thomas J. Watson of IBM Corp. in the 1930s. As it turned out, IBM’s considerable business with Nazi Germany did not advance peace.
America’s second largest trading partner is China, a country whose foreign policy is at odds with the U.S. everywhere. Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates told a meeting of the Air Force Association on Sept. 16 that Beijing’s “investments in cyber and anti-satellite warfare, anti-air and anti-ship weaponry, and ballistic missiles could threaten America’s primary way to project power and help allies in the Pacific.” America’s massive trade deficit with China has given Beijing the means to make these investments in weapons aimed at Americans.
Great Britain and Germany engaged in considerable trade in the 20th century and yet also fought two world wars. When German growth surpassed that of England, the geopolitical consequences dwarfed the prattle of economic theory. The proper role of trade is not as a substitute for policy, but as a tool of policy, as when France invested heavily in Russia before World War I to strengthen the capabilities of their alliance. Or when the British, belatedly, adopted an imperial preference tariff after World War I to pull its empire together as a more cohesive and productive unit. The United States had done the same thing by abolishing tariffs between states while maintaining protectionism against foreign rivals.
Mr. Peterson’s ivory tower theories have been turned to hash time and again over the centuries. This is why he is a libertarian - and not a conservative who looks at the real world.
WILLIAM R. HAWKINS
TWT Video Picks
By Tammy Bruce
Team Obama's bizarre behavior helps Gitmo terrorists foil justice
Get Breaking Alerts
- BOLTON: A 'three-state solution' for Middle East peace
- Obama taunts GOP, takes nationally televised victory lap on Obamacare
- With pot and e-cigarettes, Big Tobacco is just waiting to inhale emerging markets
- Jews being told to register in Ukraine: John Kerry
- Supreme Court weighs appeal to concealed-carry gun laws
- Cliven Bundy's Nevada ranch wrecked by retreating feds
- U.S. Navy to turn seawater into jet fuel
- Army goes to war with National Guard, seizes Apache attack helicopters
- Inside China: Marine's comment on islands draws sharp Chinese response
- Hustler sent to every congressional office since 1983
Recent Letters to the Editor
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Probe Boston teen's medical, custody case
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Bundy support a modern-day Tiananmen protest
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: An honorable president would resign
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Bundy support demonstrates voters' distrust
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Obamacare disasters were avoidable