- Nancy Pelosi tells Democrats to pass budget: ‘Embrace the suck’
- Key Obamacare official: Last two months much harder than anyone hoped
- Sen. Mike Lee: We must stop ‘the prez’ from acting like the queen
- George Bush consoles embattled Alabama kicker Cade Foster: You will be stronger
- Megachurch pastor with ties to Obama commits suicide
- WaPo to readers: Send us your ‘gun violence’ stories for Sandy Hook anniversary
- U.S. threatens Ukraine with sanctions over dispatch of riot police
- Canada doing away with door-to-door mail delivery by 2018
- NSA chief defends phone spying: ‘There is no other way’
- Hawaii Health Department head killed in plane crash
New trial possible in online ‘threat’ case
Question of the Day
A construction worker charged with threatening to strangle Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley could get a new trial, after a special appeals court ruled last week that a Baltimore County trial judge failed to instruct the jury on the difference between threats and political speech.
Maryland Attorney General Douglas Gansler must now decide whether to appeal to Maryland’s highest court or send the case back to Baltimore County to be retried.
On Monday, State’s Attorney for Baltimore County Leo Ryan vowed to retry the case if the state does not appeal.
“There’s always a tension between political speech and illegal speech that threatens a public official,” he said, acknowledging the error at trial. “Courts struggle with that, and rightly so.”
Walter C. Abbott Jr. of Parkville, Md., was convicted in October 2008 of making a criminal threat and sentenced to six months in jail, a $500 fine and two years’ unsupervised probation. The jail time was suspended.
The case arose in March 2008 after Mr. Abbott sent a message via the governor’s Web site, which solicited constituent feedback. Claiming he was angry that his business was hurt by the governor’s immigration and labor policies, Mr. Abbott wrote: “If I ever get close enough to you, I will wrap my hands around your throat and strangle the life from you.”
Police came to Mr. Abbott’s house within hours of the message and found a 9 mm handgun, which was registered to Mr. Abbott. They also discovered that a week earlier, he had been in Annapolis at a political event attended by the governor. Mr. Abbott, who had no criminal history of violence, was charged with threatening to injure a public official.
After rejecting a plea offer of probation before judgment, Mr. Abbott was convicted by a Baltimore County jury - but without the jury receiving a critical instruction from Judge Dana M. Levitz.
“I find it disgusting, I find it outrageous,” Judge Levitz said at trial, refusing a request by Mr. Abbott’s lawyer that he instruct the jury on the difference between a threat and free speech. “It doesn’t make any difference that you say ‘because I disagree with his politics.’ The law doesn’t permit that.”
The appeals court disagreed.
“The [judge] never informed the jury that only a true threat falls within the statute, and that political vitriol may fall outside its ambit,” the three-judge panel wrote. “The [judge] should have instructed the jury as to the requirement of a true threat, which is distinguished from constitutionally protected free speech.”
Arthur M. Frank, attorney for Mr. Abbott, hailed the ruling, saying he felt “all along that the guy didn’t get a fair trial.”
Yet Mr. Ryan, the prosecutor, insisted that Mr. Abbott’s statement clearly constituted a threat.
“You can call an official an idiot, you can call him foul names, but you can’t say you’re going to harm him,” he said.
About the Author
Jeffrey Anderson is an investigative reporter for The Washington Times. He can be reached at email@example.com.
By Matt Kibbe
The short-term deal will assure long-term overspending
- NAPOLITANO: A conspiracy so vast
- All-out war breaks out in GOP over budget pact
- Biden guarantees victory on immigration reform
- Washington Post to readers: Send us your gun violence stories for Sandy Hook anniversary
- Teen thugs in D.C. run wild -- even while wearing GPS ankle bracelets
- MALCOLM/REIMER: Over-criminalization undermines respect for legal system
- Obama takes 'selfie' at Mandela's funeral service
- MILLER: Dick Heller challenges D.C.s gun registration, files for summary judgment in Heller II
- Study IDs reasons for late-term abortions
- Chinese man fed up with his girlfriend's shopping jumps to his death
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Positive propaganda for a nation in peril.
Politics, economics, and business from a real world perspective.
All of the world’s problems, solved on your back porch
Al Maurer provides a common sense, conservatarian, Constitutional conservative perspective from the battleground state of Colorado
Extraordinary day at Redskins Park
White House pets gone wild!
Let it snow