The first lady lectured the Chinese on the benefits of the freedom of the press while refusing to take questions, do interviews or allow any reporters on her plane. The irony is striking.
Just like government-run media, the White House gave details and photos during the week only by blog, YouTube videos made by her staff and Twitter.
While refusing to talk to the media herself, Mrs. Obama said the Chinese need to respect a free press. “It’s so important for information and ideas to flow freely over the Internet and through the media because that’s how we discover the truth,” she said at Peking University.
“My husband and I are on the receiving end of plenty of questioning and criticism from our media and our fellow citizens. And it’s not always easy, but we wouldn’t trade it for anything in the world.”
She somehow missed the contradiction in her words and actions.
Richard Grenell was the U.S. spokesman at the United Nations for the eight years of President George W. Bush’s administration. “The first lady is lucky that the Chinese public doesn’t have access to the real facts showing her trip devoid of the journalists’ scrutiny she speaks of,” he told me.
Mr. Grenell, a partner with the global communications firm Capitol Media Partners, pointed out that the White House press corps does not often challenge the strict limits set by Mr. Obama’s press staff.
The White House claimed the lack of press access was because it was not a political trip. Ben Rhodes, the deputy national security adviser for communications, said the message is that “the relationship between the United States and China is not just between leaders — it’s a relationship between peoples.”
Despite what Mr. Rhodes said, Mrs. Obama met with the leader himself — President Xi Jinping. There were brief, scripted remarks at the top for the media, but no questions. The majority of the meeting was “closed press,” and the only information came on background from an aide to the first lady.
During the week in China, the only media access to the first lady came when the White House allowed a press pool of American media based in China near her. The reports that come back demonstrated the frustration that the reporters and photographers felt about the lockout.
The first lady of China, Peng Liyuan, gave Mrs. Obama a tour of the Forbidden City, but the pool was left outside. The two first ladies also enjoyed an “off the record” dinner with some kind of performance, about which the press could not get details.
At the Great Wall, the pool reporters were “sent ahead to Tower 15, and told they could not move from the top of the tower until told to do so” — while the Obamas later came through Tower 14.