- Pope Francis wins another ‘Person of the Year’ — from gay rights magazine
- Rep. Steve Stockman: Give my campaign $10, and you’ll get an Obama barf bag
- Putin: Russia to buy $15 billion in Ukraine bonds
- Expert: Obamacare ‘death spiral’ fears exaggerated
- Alabama firefighters dig for survivors of apartment blast
- Big Sur wildfire destroys home of firefighting chief
- ‘ ’Twas the Night Before Christmas’ set for mock trial to argue authorship
- Angela Merkel’s third term as Germany’s chancellor to be marked by move to left
- Mega Millions entices with record-setting jackpot: Half a billion so far
- Dennis Rodman heads to North Korea — despite execution, political purge
DNA tests help genealogists only so far
As the number of people looking for connections has grown, so has the number of critics of DNA testing. The technology does not come without caveats.
Harvard African American Studies professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. helped popularize DNA testing with a 2006 PBS special “African American Lives,” but after repeated tests with different companies, Mr. Gates said last year he had been given conflicting results. One company told him his maternal ancestors were Egyptian; another told him they were European.
Edward Ball, author of the book “The Genetic Strand,” writes that he had some ancestral hair samples tested. One company told him they were American Indian. Another company told him he had African genes but not American Indian genes. Still another told him his people came from Northern Europe.
Mr. Duster of NYU calls the business of genetic DNA testing “an unregulated no-man’s land.” He says he would like to see guidelines and transparency as the business evolves.
“Any company can claim that their laboratories can analyze your DNA to provide accurate information about your ancestry,” Mr. Duster says. “But if three different companies provide three different answers [as a report on CBS’ “60 Minutes” did in 2007], what is a consumer to do? Which company is correct? There is no way of knowing, since we have no ‘gold standard’ for excellence or professional self-policing.”
The American Society of Human Genetics (ASHG) has similar concerns. The group says that those who undergo ancestry testing often do not realize the tests are probabilistic and can reach incorrect conclusions, causing emotional distress if test results are unexpected or undesired.
The ASHG says consumers frequently purchase these tests to learn about their race or ethnicity, yet there is no clear-cut connection between an individual’s DNA and racial affiliation.
ASHG President Aravinda Chakravarti, from Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, says the group recommends greater efforts on the part of both industry and academia to make the limitations of ancestry-testing estimation more clear. Consumers, meanwhile, have a responsibility to avail themselves of information about ancestry testing and to strive to better understand the implications and limitations of these tests.
The society also called for additional research to understand testing’s accuracy and for guidelines to be developed for ethical use of testing and research.
About the Author
Karen Goldberg Goff has been a reporter at The Washington Times since 1992. She currently writes feature-length stories on a variety of topics, including family issues, pop culture, health, food and technology. Follow Karen on Twitter.
- Sweet smell of success
- Overbooked parents see little respite over holidays
- Experts debunk December suicide myth
- Having a baby in the fertility maze
- Lovelace's books remain relevant for today's girls
Latest Blog Entries
By John R. Bolton
The president fiddles at his domestic altar while the world burns
- PRUDEN: The scam that will not die
- Embassy Row: India strikes back over diplomat's arrest
- Robert E. Lee and 'Stonewall' Jackson tributes face Army War College removal
- Wasted: Tom Coburn's 'Wastebook targets 70 days in bed, Facebook
- Army to cut up to 4,000 captains and majors
- OBAMASCARE: Huge premium hikes rock employer-insured workers
- BOLTON: Nero in the White House
- ISTOOK: Enlarging his rule, shrinking the Constitution
- Zadzooks: The Joker sixth scale figure review (Sideshow Collectibles)
- 5 million fall into Obamacare coverage gap
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Uncensored exploration of issues concerning current events, civil liberties, American political advocacy, and the political and social issues facing military veterans.
NFL junkie Eric Golub reports on his favorite obsession. There is no football offseason. Every February he pretends to care about other sports while sobbing uncontrollably each Sunday until September.
Television commentary, reviews, news and nonstop DVR catch-up by Lisa King Dolloff and friends.
Wall Street news for retail investors who want to know what's going on.
Top 10 handguns in the U.S.
Extraordinary day at Redskins Park
White House pets gone wild!
Let it snow