Register for E-mail alerts. Comment on articles. Sign up today, it's easy.
Close

Lawsuit claims school bias on Christian views

Counseling student speaks up

MugshotJennifer Keeton says Augusta State University in Georgia has told her to deny her Christian beliefs in order to graduate. (Alliance Defense Fund)
Social Networks
facebookFacebook
twitterTwitter
Question of the Day

Does Sarah Palin have enough starpower and appeal to influence midterm elections?

View results

Attorneys with the Alliance Defense Fund have sued Augusta State University in Georgia on behalf of a counseling student who claims the university told her to deny her Christian beliefs in order to graduate.

Jennifer Keeton, 24, who is pursuing a master's degree in counseling, said she was ordered to undergo a re-education plan that requires her to attend "diversity sensitivity training," complete additional remedial reading and write papers to describe their effects on her beliefs, according to the lawsuit filed Wednesday.

The ultimatum: Complete this re-education plan or be expelled from ASU's Counselor Education Program.

ASU said Miss Keeton's conduct violates the code of ethics to which counselors and counselors in training are required to adhere, including those of the American Counseling Association and the American School Counselor Association.

"It's hard to conceive of a more blatant violation of her right to freedom of speech and her freedom of conscience," said David French, senior legal counsel for the Alliance Defense Fund, a conservative-leaning group that defends religious freedom. "This type of leftist zero-tolerance policy is in place at far too many universities, and it must stop."

ASU officials, in an e-mail to a Washington Times reporter, said they could not comment on the lawsuit.

"There is little I can say right now since there is a pending lawsuit. ASU does not discriminate on the basis of any individual's moral, religious, political or personal views or beliefs," said Kathy Schofe, the university's public relations director.

Erin Martz, manager of ethics and professional standards at the American Counseling Association, said that although she couldn't specifically address Miss Keeton's case, "The ACA Code of Ethics serves to ensure that counselors and counselors-in-training conduct themselves in a way which is consistent with the ideals of the profession. As such, the core values of diversity, multiculturalism and inclusion are present throughout the code and are crucial to the ethical decision-making process."

Miss Keeton's case is one of several nationwide in which counseling students have been dismissed from programs or threatened with expulsion because of their Christian beliefs.

One case involves counseling student Julea Ward, who was dismissed from Eastern Michigan University's School of Counseling after she refused to change her beliefs. After a client asked Miss Ward for advice on a same-sex relationship, she asked her adviser on how to help her client because, she said, she couldn't morally affirm such relationships. Miss Ward ultimately referred her client to another counselor. The university dismissed Miss Ward from the program in March 2009. The case is now being litigated in federal court.

Story Continues →

© Copyright 2010 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

About the Author
Rachel B. Duke

Rachel B. Duke

Rachel B. Duke is an intern with the National Journalism Center working in family and social issues and national news for the summer. She is a senior at Southern Methodist University in Dallas and will graduate in December. 

Comments

New User c502e says:

1 month ago

Mark as offensive

Wow. I love how the coverage of this story is spinning it as if she if being forced to change the core way she views the world and her relationship to it. I mean, I certainly wasn't privy to the conversations between her and the staff at ASU, but I'm imagining the real issue is something like, "Listen, when you fill the role of counselor, it is required of you by literal guidelines and informal best practice guidelines to be aware of your biases, assumptions, prejudices, and general frames through which you view the world. When filling such a role, there is a need to leave your own personal beliefs at the door b/c your job is to present as non-judgmental and open with a client helping them work through their own issues, not solving the issues for them through your own beliefs." When not filling her role, she is as free as the next person to believe and say whatever she wants. Now granted, it's extreme to have expulsion as the possible end result, but certainly not out of line to force kids, w/in a graduate program, to face head on their beliefs, thoughts, and assumptions about the world. That is a university's responsibility. Unfortunately, seems like the extreme christian right is exploiting this young naive girl.

PolishBear says:

1 month ago

Mark as offensive

By profession I am an HIV Prevention Specialist for the West Virginia Bureau for Public Health. Part of my job involves doing HIV testing and counseling; I also teach other social workers and health care professionals how to do the same. The definition of HIV prevention counseling is to assist clients in making behavior changes that can reduce their risk for acquiring or transmitting HIV. But counseling of ANY kind relies on certain skills and concepts, and one of the three important "Counseling Concepts" is this:

MANAGE YOUR OWN DISCOMFORT.

Anyone who does HIV prevention counseling is invariably going to be confronted with sexual behaviors and drug use behaviors that make us uncomfortable. But if we are unable to manage that discomfort, the counseling session will not be effective. If one of my clients feels that I'm being judgmental and sanctimonious, rather than caring and empathetic, that's going to drive a big barrier between me and that person.

Julea Ward and Jennifer Keeton are entitled to their views about homosexuality. But COUNSELING is the wrong profession for both of them, as any professional counselor will have you know.

New User c502e says:

1 month ago

Mark as offensive

Wow. I love how the coverage of this story is spinning it as if she if being forced to change the core way she views the world and her relationship to it. I mean, I certainly wasn't privy to the conversations between her and the staff at ASU, but I'm imagining the real issue is something like, "Listen, when you fill the role of counselor, it is required of you by literal guidelines and informal best practice guidelines to be aware of your biases, assumptions, prejudices, and general frames through which you view the world. When filling such a role, there is a need to leave your own personal beliefs at the door b/c your job is to present as non-judgmental and open with a client helping them work through their own issues, not solving the issues for them through your own beliefs." When not filling her role, she is as free as the next person to believe and say whatever she wants. Now granted, it's extreme to have expulsion as the possible end result, but certainly not out of line to force kids, w/in a graduate program, to face head on their beliefs, thoughts, and assumptions about the world. That is a university's responsibility. Unfortunately, seems like the extreme christian right is exploiting this young naive girl.

View all comment(s) on this article.

Post a comment

Title

Not Registered Yet?

Comment on articles. Receive e-mail newsletters and alerts. Sign up today.

Happening Now

Click for more stories

Most Read

    Independent voices from the TWT Communities

    Bill Kelly's Truth Squad

    A conservative satirist takes on the worlds of politics and entertainment in humorous pursuit of truth, justice and all things America.

    Tea Party Report

    Real news, opinion and true-life tales from everyday Americans on the front lines of the Tea Party movement. This is your story.

    Teaming Up For Success

    People celebrating good things that happen through successful teamwork.