- GM’s Barra to be first woman to run top American carmaker
- China: Poisonous smog is a military asset, if you think about it
- Texas woman admits to sending ricin to Obama
- Ron Paul on son Rand: ‘I think he probably will’ run for president
- Cold War heats up again in the Arctic: Russian airfield reactivated after 20 years
- 6-year-old boy suspended for sexual harassment over kiss
- Voters deciding Mass. congressional contest
- Holiday cheer: Airline grants Christmas wishes for 250 unsuspecting passengers
- U.S. vet held in North Korea says statement was coerced
- NTSB hearing on San Francisco airliner crash postponed
Anti-DOMA law firm loses two clients
King & Spalding dropped by NRA, state of Virginia over gay rights fight
More than a week after a top Atlanta law firm dropped the contract to defend the federal marriage statute under pressure from gay groups, the legal and public relations fallout shows no signs of easing.
In addition to losing one of its top lawyers in protest, King & Spalding has lost at least two high-profile clients, while its decision to cancel its contract with the House of Representatives to defend the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) has sparked a lively debate in the nation's law schools and on legal blogs.
Stanford Law School professor Deborah L. Rhode wrote this week in the National Law Journal that the law firm was "right to withdraw" from the case because of its concerns, but others, including U.S. Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr., have sharply criticized the move.
Separately, the National Rifle Association and the Commonwealth of Virginia have both dropped the large Atlanta-based firm from their roster of law firms, with both citing the DOMA decision.
While the firm deals with the fallout, Paul D. Clement, the respected former U.S. solicitor general who resigned from King & Spalding after the firm canceled the contract, has agreed to a new $500,000 contract with the House Administration Committee to continue the DOMA case. Mr. Clement will now help defend DOMA, which essentially rejects gay unions in the federal definition of marriage, at his new firm, Bancroft PLLC.
King & Spalding Chairman Robert D. Hays Jr. said April 25 that his firm was dropping the DOMA contract owing to "inadequate" vetting of the case.
House Republican leaders sought legal representation for DOMA after President Obama and Mr. Holder announced they would no longer defend the law, based on their belief it is unconstitutional.
In her article in the National Law Journal, Ms. Rhode wrote that while criminals need "vigorous advocacy," the "moral calculus is different" in civil cases such as the DOMA litigation.
"Except in rare circumstances, civil claimants have no right to counsel," she said. "The notion that lawyers should check their conscience at the door" has led to public policy fiascos in such areas as finance and public health, she added.
Gay rights groups were not using "McCarthyite" tactics in pressuring King & Spalding to withdraw, she added. "They were exercising their own rights to expression" in the service of their allies, which is "precisely" the "kind of pressure" that other groups have used to end discrimination.
But New York University law professor Stephen Gillers echoed many in the legal world when he said King & Spalding had "caved in."
King & Spalding can no longer be relied on as outside counsel, NRA General Counsel David Lehman wrote in a May 2 letter.
The NRA is "often involved in controversial issues," Mr. Lehman wrote. Anyone hired as outside counsel is expected to "zealously advocate for our interests and not abandon the representation due to pressure from those who may disagree with us."
Days earlier, Virginia Attorney General Kenneth T. Cuccinelli II also told the firm that its services were no longer needed for any state agency as long as he was in office.
Dropping the DOMA contract "was such an obsequious act of weakness that I feel compelled to end your legal association with Virginia, so there is no chance that one of my legal clients" will be similarly discarded, Mr. Cuccinelli wrote to King & Spalding official Joseph E. Lynch.
© Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Cheryl Wetzstein covers family and social issues as a national reporter for The Washington Times. She has been a reporter for three decades, working in New York City and Washington, D.C. Since joining The Washington Times in 1985, she has been a features writer, environmental and consumer affairs reporter, and assistant business editor. Beginning in 1994, Mrs. Wetzstein worked exclusively ...
- Panel seeks 'surveillance' system for gay blood donors
- Pregnancies decline overall, up among older women
- Embryonic stem cell research falls out of favor as scientists go ethical
- With new HIV research, FDA may let gay men donate blood
- HHS report shows a decrease in blood supply but also a drop in demand
Latest Blog Entries
- Pro-life, stem-cell bill signed into law by Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback
- N. Dakota lawmakers approve tough abortion bill
- Pope Benedict XVI's successor should allow priests to get a new title: Husband, poll finds
- House votes to reject Obama welfare shift
- Report: Two out of three Democrats support gay marriage
By Tom Fitton
New photos confirm the attack's coordination and its cover-up
- American bourbon now better than Scottish whiskey: U.K.-born expert
- Obama takes 'selfie' at Mandela's funeral service
- FITTON: A closer look at the Benghazi lie
- Chinese man fed up with his girlfriend's shopping jumps to his death
- Troops forced to rely on welfare, holiday charity
- Israeli P.M. Benjamin Netanyahu backs out of Nelson Mandela funeral
- PRUDEN: Waiting for Nelson Mandela without the tears
- Oregon fails to sign up single person on health care website as states struggle
- Obama shakes hands with Cuba's Raul Castro at Nelson Mandela's funeral
- Obama lied about Syrian chemical attack, 'cherry-picked' intelligence: report
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Global economy, the civilizing power of markets and public morals.
News and opinion from a Millennial Urbanite with Southern sensibilities,
Notes from a running nerd: musings and more on all things running.
NFL junkie Eric Golub reports on his favorite obsession. There is no football offseason. Every February he pretends to care about other sports while sobbing uncontrollably each Sunday until September.
White House pets gone wild!
Let it snow