- Obama military downsizing leaves U.S. too weak to counter global threats, panel finds
- Sen. Tom Coburn vows to slow down budget-busting bills ahead of recess
- Obama fantasizes about more executive power, signs new order on federal contractors
- Clintons call Klein, Halper, Kessler ‘a Hat Trick of despicable actors’: report
- Boehner accuses Obama of ‘legacy of lawlessness’
- Pro-marijuana group claims responsibility for Brooklyn Bridge flag swap
- Young adults shun Obamacare mostly due to cost: survey
- Stabbing attack on transgender girl, 15, was ‘bias motivated,’ police say
- LGBT adults still lean overwhelmingly toward Democratic Party
- Lawmakers rattled by Syria genocide horrors, call on Obama to act
USAID’s role in covert work questioned
Question of the Day
It was part of John F. Kennedy's New Frontier: a government agency to work with developing countries around the world and spread democracy in the process.
Fifty years later, the U.S. Agency for International Development faces skepticism from other countries about its true purpose and warnings from critics who say it has strayed too much into the world of clandestine operations.
The imprisonment in Cuba of USAID subcontractor Alan Gross, who secretly brought in communications equipment to the country, has raised questions whether the aid agency has endangered its workers, even those who operate in the open.
During five trips to the island nation, Mr. Gross told those who asked that he worked with a Jewish humanitarian mission while bringing in laptops, iPods and other technology for Jewish communities. He was arrested and sentenced last year to 15 years in prison after he set up satellite Internet communications using specialized technology to prevent detection by Cuban authorities.
Critics say such covert work should best be left to intelligence agencies, not a development agency like USAID.
“USAID’s mission is best served when it does things in a transparent manner,” said Joseph Siegle, a researcher at the Center for International and Security Studies at the University of Maryland. “USAID risks losing its credibility if it goes outside that approach.”
The tactics also trouble William Fisher, who managed economic development programs for the State Department and USAID for more than 30 years.
“I may be a traditionalist, but I don’t think there is a place for this secret work at USAID,” he said.
If the aid agency gets a reputation for doing secret work, governments that normally welcome its traditional aid work could become more suspicious, he said.
“It certainly puts USAID workers, consultants and staff at great risk,” Mr. Fisher added. “If they act like the CIA, instead of an aid agency, it seems to me that it would threaten USAID’s very basic mission.”
Others maintain that the agency must work to spread democracy even in hostile countries, or its aid programs will fail.
“The relevant question is: Do we expect aid programs to be effective in undemocratic countries?” said John Norris, a former USAID disaster expert and an analyst at the Washington-based Center for American Progress think tank. “And we know pretty well that they won’t work.”
USAID has said that its contractors don’t perform covert work, but act discreetly to ensure their workers’ safety and the safety of those they are trying to help. Yet the agency has often had to counter accusations and suspicions about its aims in countries that don’t trust U.S. motives, putting inexperienced workers at risk, experts say.
“USAID doesn’t have the professional expertise, it doesn’t have the same kind of feel or touch for these operations that the [CIA] would,” said Lawrence Wilkerson, chief of staff for Secretary of State Colin Powell from 2001 to 2005 during the Bush administration. “You get people in trouble this way, especially in a country that is antagonistic.”
USAID recently redesigned the website for its Pakistan programs, said Danny Cutherell, a Pakistan analyst at the Center for Global Development. The new version seeks to show specific development objectives and results, and describes in detail how the work is carried out. The change followed the August kidnapping of an aid worker whose company was funded by USAID. Al Qaeda claimed responsibility.
TWT Video Picks
Both parties recognize the Democrats' scam
- Inside the Ring: Israel surprised by Hamas tunnel network
- CRUZ: A tale of two hospitals: One in Israel, one in Gaza
- Obama military strategy too weak for future security, panel reports
- Catholic League slams Obama: 'Do Christian lives mean so little to you?'
- CIA admits improperly hacking Senate computers in search of Bush-era information
- Chicken pox outbreak puts illegal immigrant facility on lockdown
- HUSAIN: Fleeing Iraqi Christians find safe haven at the Shrine of Imam Ali
- Israel surprised by Hamas tunnel network
- Iraq Christians get meeting with top Obama aide
- 'Big Bang' star Mayim Bialik helps send bulletproof vests to IDF
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world