- Extra-time goal gives Germany World Cup title over Argentina
- Strong quake hits Japan, triggering tsunami
- Sniper heaven: Pentagon’s self-guided bullets leave enemies nowhere to hide
- Violent gang taking advantage of immigration crisis, using border as recruiting hub
- Medicaid enrollment continues to soar under Obamacare, administration says
- Michelle Obama to Latinos: ‘We cannot afford to wait on Congress’ for immigration
- White House urges GOP to act ‘urgently’ on $3.7 billion request for illegal immigrants
- Politicians, criminals using ‘right-to-be-forgotten’ law EU courts forced upon Google
- Combat fatigue: elite special forces troops are ‘fraying,’ Gen. Joseph Votel warns
- German foreign minister to meet Kerry to discuss spying claims
Michigan plan offers tuition-free education
Cost to state of proposal: $1.8B yearly
Question of the Day
In a bid to broaden college access and boost the state’s lagging economy, Democrats in Michigan have proposed a first-of-its-kind entitlement program aimed at giving many young people a free ride through college at taxpayers’ expense.
The proposal, dubbed “the 2020 Plan,” is estimated to cost at least $1.8 billion each year and would offer some students free tuition throughout their college careers at Michigan’s 15 public colleges and universities, with awards based on how long students have lived in the state. Those who spend all of their K-12 years in Michigan schools would be eligible for the full amount, the average tuition rate across the state university system, which is currently about $9,500 per year.
Students attending a public college with tuition rates above that average would be responsible for the difference.
After struggling for years to balance its budget, Michigan ended the last fiscal year with a surplus of more than $450 million, and Republicans aren’t surprised that their Democratic colleagues have quickly come up with new ways to use it.
“There’s no shortage of people coming to the door with ideas of how to spend that additional money,” said state Sen. Phil Pavlov, a Republican who chairs the Senate Education Committee.
“It just seems like another social program,” he said of the Democratic proposal. “There’s this presumption out there that Michigan is flush with additional revenue, but I don’t know where [Democrats] plan on coming with an additional $1.8 billion every year.”
To fund their idea, Democrats have spoken in generalities about closing “tax loopholes” put in place by “special interest lobbyists” and others. So far, no specific budget cuts or tax code changes have been put forth.
State Sen. Rebekah Warren, a Democrat and co-author of the proposal, said on Thursday that “specific recommendations” of how to pay for the program were intentionally left out. She envisions the creation of a new state commission, comprised of lawmakers from both parties, to hammer out the details.
Ms. Warren and other Democrats remain confident that $1.8 billion or more in waste and unnecessary tax breaks can be eliminated through a careful examination of the state budget. They also believe that the future economic rewards of their proposal, chief among them a more educated, job-ready population, far outweigh the steep upfront costs.
“Graduates have $40,000 or more of student loan debt [after college], so they’re pressured by having to get the best possible job so they can pay for that monkey on their back,” she said. “We are losing young people who don’t get the chance to say, ‘I love Michigan, but I can’t raise my kids here because I have to go get a better job elsewhere to pay off my student loan debt.’ “
Critics point out that, like other entitlement programs, costs are nearly impossible to predict. With college tuition rates rising year after year, a program that costs $1.8 billion now could easily cost twice as much in a decade.
To counter that, Ms. Warren hopes the 2020 Plan will create a competitive system between public institutions, which she believes would strive to keep costs down or risk losing students. Since the state would pay only the average tuition rate, colleges that raise rates far above that average would be less appealing, Ms. Warren said.
The reality, however, could end up being quite different. Some education specialists believe that colleges and universities, guaranteed to be paid in full each year by Michigan taxpayers, would squeeze money from their students by hiking athletic, technology and a variety of other fees not technically covered under the tuition umbrella.
“You can bet that every public university in Michigan will put special fees on everything under the sun. If you want to go use the toilet in the student center, you’ll have to pay a buck,” said Richard Vedder, director of the Center for College Affordability and Productivity, a nonprofit higher education think tank.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Ben Wolfgang covers the White House for The Washington Times.
Before joining the Times in March 2011, Ben spent four years as a political reporter at the Republican-Herald in Pottsville, Pa.
He can be reached at email@example.com.
- President Obama says he prefers results, not 'photo ops'
- Obama's 'blank check' rejected as border solution
- Iranian foreign minister: 'We don't see any benefit in Iran developing a nuclear weapon'
- 'Be a leader' — Perry tells Obama to confront border crisis
- Eric Holder on Palin: 'She wasn't a particularly good vice presidential candidate'
Latest Blog Entries
TWT Video Picks
By Robert N. Tracci
Congress must use its appropriations power to secure the border
- DOJ investigates Nebraska parade float critical of Obama
- Violent gang MS-13 taking advantage of immigration crisis, using border as recruiting hub
- 9-year-old girl dies from brain-eating amoeba
- A 'new Cold War': China's top paper warns of 'slippery slope' towards conflict with U.S.
- New York City creates ID card so 500K illegal immigrants can get services
- CURL: The hypocrisy of Obama's 15-day Vineyard vacation
- Germany wins World Cup title on Mario Goetze goal in extra time
- Armed militia sets up Texas command center to 'fight for national sovereignty'
- Pentagon's self-guided bullets leave enemies nowhere to hide
- Economists see signs of another market bubble
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world
Fighting in Iraq
World Cup's sexiest WAGs