Even though traffic often grinds to a standstill on some of its biggest highways, Virginia is suddenly attracting intense nationwide attention.
With states across the country facing growing mismatches between their gas-tax revenues and the bills they face to build and repair roads and bridges, Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell’s proposal to junk the state’s gas tax altogether — coupled with an increase in the state’s sales tax rate — represents a radical turn.
“Virginia’s proposal is, by and large, unprecedented,” said Jaime Rall, senior transportation policy specialist at the National Conference of State Legislatures in Denver. “I think by putting forward such a bold proposal, this has the potential to increase attention on the national crisis in transportation funding.”
Look for other states to keep tabs on how the Virginia experiment pans out as they wrestle with their own highway-funding shortfalls. All 50 states have gas taxes, which provide about 40 percent of highway funds — but many are scrambling in the face of a fiscal squeeze: With modern cars getting more miles per gallon and Americans on average driving 6 percent less miles per year than they did a decade ago (23 percent less for drivers younger than 35), the traditional tax on gas at the pump isn’t bringing in what it once did, even as the nation’s infrastructure bills increase.
That has governors and state legislators in both parties rethinking the economics of the gas tax. Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder, a Republican, is proposing a $1.2 billion increase in gas taxes and higher auto registrations, a tack also taken by Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick, a Democrat, who called on lawmakers to more than double the Bay State’s gas tax from 21 cents to 51 cents a gallon.
In New Hampshire, Democratic state lawmakers are backing an increase in the state gas tax from about 19 cents a gallon to 30 cents, to bring an estimated $115 million a year for state and local road building and maintenance.
Mr. McDonnell’s idea to march in the other direction already has provoked a sharp debate.
Pro-tax liberals argue that the plan, which advanced in a House committee Wednesday, abolishes a needed source of government revenue while harming the environment by encouraging more driving. They also object to the governor’s proposed tax on vehicles that run on electricity or natural gas, calling it the “Prius tax.”
Anti-tax conservatives, meanwhile, point out that the proposal fails to ease the net tax burden on Virginians, given that the governor wants to replace the state’s “outdated gas tax revenue model” by increasing the 5 percent sales tax to 5.8 percent.
Even advocates of greater highway spending and investment aren’t thrilled with the proposal. “It just seems a little wild,” said Greg Cohen, president of the American Highway Users Alliance in Washington.
That may be the best thing about the Republican governor’s proposal: Whatever its flaws, the $3.1 billion plan is so headline-grabbing that it has thrust critical but unexciting transportation and infrastructure issues to the policy forefront.
“By investing over $3.1 billion into our transportation system over the next five years, we can finally fix transportation in Virginia once and for all,” House Speaker William J. Howell and his three top lieutenants said in a statement. “We fully support this proposal and will work hard for its passage in the House of Delegates.”