Syria creates a Russian safe zone, civilian danger zones

Question of the Day

Is it still considered bad form to talk politics during a social gathering?

View results

Syria’s military is preparing for a U.S. strike by dispersing its forces into apartment buildings, schools and mosques, and may be hiding its most valuable assets inside a Russian naval base, betting that U.S. missiles will avoid it.

“There is some evidence that the Syrian military is treating the Russian base at Tartus as a safe zone,” said Christopher Harmer, a senior naval analyst at the Institute for the Study of War.

Reports from Damascus say Syria’s regime has been moving potential targets often under the cover of darkness, and the main Western-backed opposition group says Syria’s army in the past week has moved troops, rocket launchers, artillery and other heavy weapons into residential neighborhoods in cities nationwide — raising the specter of human shields and civilian collateral damage.

Syria’s repositioning of troops and weapons underscores the risks of President Obama’s decision to seek congressional authorization for a limited attack on the regime for its use of chemical weapons Aug. 21. The president last week deployed warships in the Mediterranean and Red seas, but suddenly announced Saturday that he would get approval from Congress before launching an attack.

Tartus, Syria’s second-largest city on the Mediterranean, is home to Russia’s only naval base outside its borders.

Mr. Harmer, a 20-year Navy veteran, said Syrian President Bashar Assad’s military leadership “believes the [U.S.] strikes will not target” the base, which was established in the 1970s under an agreement with the Soviet Union.

“The Assad regime is moving tracked vehicles into Tartus,” Mr. Harmer said, adding that his information came from verbal reports collected by his contacts on the ground and transmitted via email and social media.

He acknowledged that it is not possible to tell whether the equipment being moved is Syrian or Russian, but said he is “90 percent confident that either Assad or the Russians are moving at least some high-value equipment into the Russian base.”

Jeffrey White, a defense intelligence analyst who has watched the Syrian military for many years, concurred with Mr. Harmer’s assessment.

“That would make sense especially for very high-value systems” such as the control units for Syrian anti-ship missiles, Mr. White said.

Meanwhile, three Damascus residents, speaking on the condition of anonymity for fear of reprisals, confirmed Syrian military movements of personnel and weapons, The Associated Press reported Tuesday.

One man said two members of the elite Republican Guard broke into an empty house he owns and showed him an official document stating that they were authorized to do so because Syria is at war. A woman in another area said soldiers moved into a school next to her house.

A U.S. official also confirmed indications that the Syrian regime is taking steps to move some of its military equipment and bolster protection for defense facilities, the AP reported.

“They are dispersing into civilian areas and relocating to civilian facilities,” said Mr. White, recalling that the same tactics were used with limited success by Libya’s armed forces during the NATO bombing campaign in 2011.

He noted that the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah had more success in doing the same thing during the Israeli invasion of 2006, “making it more difficult [for the Israelis] to strike their targets and raising the risk to the Israelis” of civilian casualties.

Mr. White, a researcher at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, said he also would expect Syria to use more conventional denial and deception tactics, “like hiding artillery pieces under camouflage or in buildings, using decoys, fake targets [and] fake damage.”

Calling such tactics “old school,” he said “they can make it a lot harder to hit what you want to hit and to work out afterwards whether you did or not.”

“They have a repertoire of tricks they can use,” he said. “The question is, is our intelligence good enough to see through them, and is our target agile, nimble enough to strike fleeting targets, targets of opportunity?”

There would certainly be a lot of mobile targets, Mr. Harmer said.

“Anything that is mobile, the Syrians are moving,” he said. “They are dispersing troop concentrations most of their artillery is either [motorized] or towable,” which left fixed installations such as runways or air traffic control towers as the best stationary targets for U.S. air power.

“It’s not like ‘91,” he said, referring to the U.S. airstrikes that softened Saddam Hussein’s Iraqi military before the U.S.-led land invasion that drove it out of Kuwait. In that bombing campaign, many of the targets were command-and-control facilities such as military telephone exchanges.

Mr. Harmer said the Assad regime’s forces are “not functioning like a traditional military with a very tight, top-down, command-and-control structure.” Instead, the regime is setting strategic goals and relying on a combination of regular army units, local and national militias and Hezbollah fighters to carry them out.

Syrian military leaders also are using “nontraditional” communications such as email and cellphones to send orders into the field, he said.

“It is a hodgepodge, nothing remotely resembling a coherent chain of command,” Mr. Harmer said, adding that “attacking their chain of command connectivity” would be less effective.

© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

About the Author
Shaun Waterman

Shaun Waterman

Shaun Waterman is an award-winning reporter for The Washington Times, covering foreign affairs, defense and cybersecurity. He was a senior editor and correspondent for United Press International for nearly a decade, and has covered the Department of Homeland Security since 2003. His reporting on the Sept. 11 Commission and the tortuous process by which some of its recommendations finally became ...

Latest Stories

Latest Blog Entries

Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
TWT Video Picks