- The Washington Times - Thursday, April 30, 2009


The return of Sen. Arlen Specter to the Democratic Party (he flipped in 1965 from “Kennedy Democrat” to Republican) is something that should be celebrated by Republicans, at least those who are proud to call themselves conservatives. Mr. Specter is a career politician whose first priority is himself.

Mr. Specter, whose predictable lament that the Republican Party is not the “big tent” he had been led to believe it was, now embraces a Democratic Party that is an even smaller tent. How many pro-life Democrats exercise any influence in that party? How many opponents of same-sex marriage are in the Democratic leadership? Smaller government? Lower taxes? No leading Democrat, inside or outside Congress, subscribes to such things. Yet the big media and many pundits continue the fiction that Republicans are in electoral trouble because they do not tolerate liberal ideas.

The day Democrats embrace those holding conservative ideas and implement at least some of them will be the day Republicans can be told to water down their principles. In fact, Republicans in recent years have behaved more like Democrats than Republicans and have paid the electoral price for doing so.

Republicans under President George W. Bush added to the size and cost of government. Republicans created new spending programs and increased the reach of the federal government in education and other areas. The major difference between Republicans and Democrats these days is this: Democrats know how to use power when they get it; Republicans, when they gain power, spend most of their political capital trying to prove they are not mean, uncaring, racist, sexist and homophobic. Republicans masquerade as Democrats and want to be liked. Democrats live to rule.

The Republican Party, much to the consternation of conservatives, saved Mr. Specter’s bacon in the 2004 election. Part of Karl Rove’s strategy was to re-elect Republicans, no matter how liberal. Mr. Specter won that election thanks to the efforts of the Bush White House and gobs of Republican National Committee money that was poured into his race. How sharper than a serpent’s tooth it is to have a thankless politician.

Mr. Specter switched parties because of the serious primary challenge he faced from conservative Pat Toomey. As recently as six weeks ago, Mr. Specter told the Hill newspaper that he would not become a Democrat because the country needs a vibrant two-party system. What happened? Mr. Specter acknowledged to reporters that poll data showed he would lose the primary to Mr. Toomey. He also said he was promised financial help by Pennsylvania Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell should he convert.

The Republican Party is better off without Mr. Specter, who, along with other “moderates,” has weakened the party. These RINOs (Republicans in name only) have kept the party from renewing its conservative roots and contrasting itself with the liberal wing of the Democratic Party.

Liberals do not win elections for Republicans. Conservatives win elections. Whenever conservatives try to placate liberals and show how sensitive and caring and in touch with the feelings and concerns of the other party they are, they lose. But when Republicans stand on principles and demonstrate conviction and give evidence that their ideas work, they win.

Yes, Arlen Specter kept his word not to let his pro-abortion views get in the way of the confirmations of Supreme Court Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. and Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. In return for that promise, he was allowed to remain chairman of the Judiciary Committee. That was a triumph not of Mr. Specter’s conviction, but of pragmatism. If Mr. Specter were a pro-life Democrat, the liberal wing of the party he is entering would have stripped him of his chairmanship. Can anyone say John Dingell? The “moderate” Michigan Democrat was removed as chairman of the Committee on Energy and Commerce and replaced by the ultraliberal Rep. Henry A. Waxman of California.

Democrats play for keeps. Too often, Republicans play for good reviews from those who hate them and wish to defeat their policies. Good riddance to Mr. Specter. The Republican challenge now should be to focus on what works, not ideology, though ideology should drive successful policies. Republicans can beat Democrats on that line, but they will continue losing elections if they stress only ideological purity instead of demonstrating that their principles are superior to those of welfare-state Democrats.

Mr. Specter’s self-serving switch ought to make it easier for the Republican Party, but will it?

Cal Thomas is a nationally syndicated columnist.

Sign up for Daily Opinion Newsletter

Manage Newsletters

Copyright © 2020 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide