- Rep. Lee: Paul Ryan out of touch with urban Americans
- House votes down resolution to force Issa to apologize
- Kremlin blocks opposition websites; Kasparov fears Putin plans ‘something drastic’
- Saving trees? EPA wastes $1.5 million storing unneeded pamphlets in warehouse
- Scott Brown Senate bid in New Hampshire may launch soon
- Jeffrey Corzine, son of ex-N.J. governor, dead at 31
- Australian surfing magazine sorry for calling indigenous surfer ‘apeish’
- Records: Man in Fla. theater shooting also was texting
- The Putin problem: U.S. needs Russian rockets for spy satellites
- Florida cops ticket toddler in toy convertible: report
Judge voids part of Obamacare
Ruling says law stretches bounds of Constitution
In a major setback for the Obama administration, a federal judge in Virginia struck down as unconstitutional a key provision of the landmark health care law, saying that forcing all Americans to buy health insurance “exceeds the constitutional boundaries of congressional power.”
“At its core, this dispute is not simply about regulating the business of insurance — of crafting a scheme of universal health insurance coverage — it’s about an individual’s right to choose to participate,” U.S. District Judge Henry E. Hudson in Richmond said in a 42-page opinion.
Judge Hudson concluded that Congress lacked the power under the commerce clause “to compel an individual to involuntarily engage in a private commercial transaction,” warning that the “unchecked expansion of congressional power” as suggested by the law “would invite unbridled exercise of federal police powers.”
There are other pending challenges to the health care law, which has been upheld by two other trial court judges. The Supreme Court is therefore likely to decide the law’s ultimate fate — a process that could take up to two years.
Judge Hudson’s ruling was broadly critical of the health care act, signed into law in March and known as the Affordable Care Act. However, the ruling applies only to the mandate that Americans must buy health insurance and those provisions that hinge on it. The law as a whole was not struck down, and the judge declined to grant an injunction that would have suspended the law immediately.
The Obama administration argued that the requirement to purchase health care insurance amounted to a tax and, as a result, was allowable under Congress‘ taxing powers. The commerce clause gives Congress the authority to regulate the trade of goods or commodities with foreign nations and among the states.
“A thorough survey of pertinent constitutional case law has yielded no reported decisions from any federal appellate courts extending the Commerce Clause … to encompass regulation of a person’s decision not to purchase a product,” the judge wrote.
Judge Hudson, named to be bench in 2002 by President George W. Bush, sided with Virginia Attorney General Kenneth T. Cuccinelli II, whose lawsuit defended a new state law prohibiting the government from forcing residents to buy health insurance. Virginia asserted that an Obama administration requirement that citizens buy health insurance by 2014 — when most of the law’s provisions kick in — or pay a penalty was unconstitutional.
Mr. Cuccinelli argued that while the federal government can regulate economic activity that has an impact on interstate commerce, a decision not to buy health insurance was inactivity and thus beyond the government’s reach.
At a news conference Monday, Mr. Cuccinelli applauded the ruling, saying the case was not about health insurance or health care, “it’s about liberty.”
“The ruling is extremely positive for anyone who believes in the system of federalism created by our Founding Fathers,” he said. “It underscores that our Constitution’s limitations on federal power really do mean something.”
Though the Virginia Republican said he understands that many people can’t afford health insurance and that the system “obviously needs to be fixed,” he added that “as someone who has sworn to uphold the law, I can’t endorse the taking away the rights of some people to fund the health insurance for other people.”
He also predicted that by the end of January, half the states will have signed on as parties to a lawsuit against the federal government to rein in its “overstepping the boundaries of the Constitution.”
“This is truly unique and it speaks to the severity of the breach of the constitutional boundaries that has occurred here, and it also speaks to the reaction from the country,” he said.
An ABC News/Washington Post poll found that support for the health care legislation is at a new low with 52 percent opposed and 43 percent in favor — down from a high of 48 percent in favor in November 2009.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Jerry Seper is the investigative editor for The Washington Times.
- With bombs away, drug traffickers and illegal immigrants make their play
- Medical-device company exec admits to bilking shareholders of $400M
- Justice Dept: Florida's disabled children unnecessarily put in nursing facilities
- Man gets 11 years in Philadelphia mob crackdown
- Eric Holder asks for respect from protesters of George Zimmerman verdict
Latest Blog Entries
TWT Video Picks
By Emily Miller
Obama is losing the debate on gun ownership, concealed-carry permits
- USS Kidd sent to Indian Ocean after 'indication' of Malaysian jet crash
- F-35 secrets now showing up in Chinas stealth fighter
- U.S. pilot scares off Iranians with 'Top Gun'-worthy stunt: 'You really ought to go home'
- Oil rig worker says he saw missing plane go down: report
- GOP bill tries to pull courts into fight with Obama on executive power, enforcing laws
- MILLER: Law enforcement realizes good people with guns deter crime
- NRA shirt gets N.Y. high school student suspended
- VIDEO: Emily Miller on Fox Business on Vivec Murthy for surgeon general and smart guns
- Ben Carson: America's now 'very much like Nazi Germany'
- After three days, Redskins finally address defensive needs
Chaos as Manhattan building explodes
Pope Francis meets his 'mini-me'
Celebrity deaths in 2014
Winter storm hits states — again