Gen. David H. Petraeus on Tuesday softened Obama administration rhetoric that a U.S. troop withdrawal from Afghanistan would begin in July 2011, telling a Capitol Hill panel that such a move would be “based on conditions.”
“July 2011 is not the date where we race for the exits,” the general told the Senate Armed Services Committee. “It is the date where, having done an assessment, we begin a process of transition of tasks to Afghan security forces.”
Gen. Petraeus gave the testimony moments before he slumped at the witness table and excused himself from the room. The general returned about 20 minutes later, but committee Chairman Carl Levin, Michigan Democrat, postponed the rest the hearing.
Mr. Levin, prior to adjourning the hearing, asked the general whether the president’s promise to begin withdrawing troops by July 2011 “represent[ed] your best personal professional judgment.”
After a pause, the general said that “in a perfect world, Mr. Chairman, we have to be very careful with timeliness.”
“We are assuming that we will have those kinds of conditions [in Afghanistan] that will enable that by that time in July 2011,” he said. “That’s the projection. And that is what again we have supported.”
Sen. John McCain of Arizona, the committee’s top Republican, questioned the wisdom of establishing a withdrawal timeline, saying that it could convince “the key actors inside and outside of Afghanistan that the United States is more interested in leaving than succeeding in this conflict.”
“As a result, they’re all making the necessary accommodations for a post-American Afghanistan,” Mr. McCain said.
Gen. Petraeus, in response to Mr. McCain, reiterated that his goal is for a “responsible drawdown of our forces.”
President Obama announced in December that 30,000 additional military personnel would be sent to Afghanistan this year. Almost 21,000 have been deployed, which is slightly ahead of schedule, the general said.
The president at the time said the troop surge would allow the U.S. and its allies to accelerate their goal of handing over security responsibilities to Afghan forces and would “allow us to begin the transfer of our forces out of Afghanistan in July of 2011.”
The president added that, “Just as we have done in Iraq, we will execute this transition responsibly, taking into account conditions on the ground.”
Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates, while visiting Afghanistan in March, said that some of the troops involved in the surge could be withdrawn before July 2011, though he added that those decisions would be “conditions-based.”