An education center planned as a complement to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall earned an important go-ahead from the National Capital Planning Commission, which supporters say is one step closer to a dedicated space for all military services, but critics worry it could be a step backward for the sanctity of the memorial.
Plans for the $85 million project include exhibits to highlight soldiers and memories of the Vietnam War in the context of American military history from the 18th century to today.
“The unique nature of this whole enterprise is to celebrate service to the country using the synergy of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial and the magnificence of the site,” Mr. Scruggs said. “The whole point of the education center is this is a place to educate young people, visitors to Washington, on the principles of duty, courage and honor.”
The 35,000 square foot education center is planned for a plot of empty land north of the Lincoln Memorial Circle and across Henry Bacon Drive on the northwest side of the memorial wall.
Roughly 4 million visitors descend annually into the jagged space carved out of the gently sloped Mall ground. There, etched into polished black granite panels, are the names of more than 58,000 soldiers killed or missing in action during the Vietnam War. On any given day, visitors can be seen pressing a name onto a piece of paper or leaving a memento at the foot of the wall.
It is this preservation of solemn reverence that has Judy Scott Feldman, chairwoman of the Coalition to Save Our Mall, concerned about the center.
Her objection comes not from a rejection of honoring military service, but “an appreciation and deep feeling for the memorial itself.”
“It’s a powerful place for reconciliation and understanding,” she said. “When you have something as powerful as that, then you add something else, you can’t help the memorial. That’s the major objection: We are diminishing the memorial by adding this.”
Under the proposed design plans, visitors to the education center would visit an exhibit that traces American military history before going to another room where photographs of every name on the memorial wall are shown on an enormous screen.
Ms. Feldman suggested that instead of an education center — which might be the only stop for some visitors not interested in seeing the wall — the memorial fund could just allow visitors to access the collections of pictures and records of soldiers on the wall online with computers, smartphones and tablets.
It takes many years after a war has ended before a memorial can be built on the Mall, Mr. Scruggs explained, “for history to kind of figure out what was the impact of that war.”
The education center is not going to be a memorial for the Afghanistan or Iraq wars, but “this will be a place they all come … until they get their own memorial,” he said.
But it’s just that idea of attempting to unite all soldiers and putting faces to names that irritates Vietnam veteran Ray Saikus.
The Cleveland resident, who is active in the Equal Honor for All organization, said the center is “contrary to the intent of the memorial.”