- Mexican train carrying 1,300 migrants headed toward U.S. derails
- Secret Service begins regular K-9 patrols around White House
- Pentagon’s human memory-chip program moves forward
- Obama blasts GOP, ignores immigration crisis in Texas speech
- Marine Warfighting Lab tests the Godzilla of amphibious assault vehicles
- Harry Reid: Birth-control ruling the worst Supreme Court decision in 25 years
- Vet suicides ‘horrible human cost’ of VA dysfunction: lawmaker
- First marijuana customer in Spokane says he was fired
- Hagel: ‘Make no mistake,’ ISIL is an ‘imminent’ threat to U.S.
- Armed militia sets up Texas command center to ‘fight for national sovereignty’
SNYDER: Gray areas abound in determining what’s clean, what’s dirty in NFL
Question of the Day
On one hand, the story that has roiled the NFL since Friday is a complex study in meaning, intent and extent. On the other hand, it’s a simple open-and-shut case of the New Orleans Saints continuing to violate league rules after being warned to cease and desist.
The Saints, rightfully so, will pay a heavy price for their cash rewards program. It doesn’t matter if similar programs exist on every team to varying degrees. It doesn’t matter if pay-for-performance kitties have been around for decades. And it doesn’t matter if the Saints‘ opponents suffered no long-term injuries as a result of the policy.
The league said “quit it” and New Orleans refused to comply. Stiff punishment is warranted.
And thus concludes the black-and-white portion of this topic. The rest is a mess of multi-hued grays, with subliminal messages like “hypocrisy” and “naivety” flashing across your mind’s eye.
Part of the problem resides in the sport itself. Football requires participants to suspend conventional wisdom about self-preservation, namely that you shouldn’t run into other human beings at full speed, and certainly not repeatedly. Those who master the art can earn college scholarships before proceeding to pro careers and fat paychecks.
Defensive players on the Saints and other teams are paid to hit often and hit hard, in hopes of separating opponents from the ball. If opponents are separated from their senses as well, that comes with the territory. As long as it’s done cleanly, within the rules and spirit of the game, there’s nothing wrong.
For instance, take the play in which former Arizona quarterback Kurt Warner was blasted by former Saints defensive end Bobby McCray in a 2010 playoff game. McCray unloaded on an unsuspecting Warner, who broke the cardinal rule of keeping one’s head on a swivel during interception returns. The hit was vicious, but clean, and essentially sent Warner into retirement.
Which brings us to the irony, contradictions and fine line between bounties, game balls and big hits.
If Warner pops up, seemingly unaffected, and continues to play, McCray accepts hearty congratulations from teammates. Coach Sean Payton might mention McCray during the postgame speech in the locker room and award him a game ball.
But Warner lay there, dazed and confused, which automatically short-circuits celebrations by the defensive players. They typically want to “hurt” opponents, as in making them feel it when they’re hit, but not really “hurt” them, as in leaving them with a serious injury.
However, now that we’ve learned of the Saints‘ “bounty program,” in which players allegedly received $1,500 for “knockouts” and $1,000 for “cart-offs,” with payouts doubling or tripling during the playoffs, McCray’s hit looks questionable.
Was he just making a clean, hard football play? Or was he intentionally trying to force Warner from the game?
As in other fields and situations, the appearance of a conflict of interest is as bad as an actual conflict of interest. That’s why the NFL prohibits bounties/bonuses, even though they arguably have little impact on game results or injury rates.
“Trying to legislate intent is very, very hard,” former Baltimore coach Brian Billick said Tuesday on the Colin Cowherd Show. “But clearly, the commissioner wants to shoot that shot over the bow and make sure everyone knows the league is watching and not going to let it happen.”
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Deron Snyder is an award-winning journalist and Washington Times sports columnist with more than 25 years of experience. He has worked at USA Today and his column was syndicated in Gannett’s 80-plus newspapers from 2000-2009, appearing in The Arizona Republic, The Indianapolis Star, The Detroit News and many others. Follow Deron on Twitter @DeronSnyder or email him at firstname.lastname@example.org.
- SNYDER: Robert Griffin III worth his weight in bronze to Baylor
- SNYDER: Upon further review, MLB instant replay remains beholden to human element
- SNYDER: Musings on Bryce Harper, Tim Howard and more
- SNYDER: Turns out, Jurgen Klinsmann pushed the right buttons for U.S.
- SNYDER: LeBron James, Carmelo Anthony make NBA offseason worth watching
Latest Blog Entries
- Armed militia sets up Texas command center to 'fight for national sovereignty'
- HUSAIN: The fake caliph of 'The Islamic State'
- IRS employee suspended for pro-Obama activities
- HUSAR: Mexicos Pena Nieto passes the immigration bucket
- GOP: Lerner warned IRS employees to hide information from Congress
- Va. Democrat reportedly seeks nude shots of Kendall Jones
- Tiger Woods' swing changes have hurt his game, Paul Azinger says
- ISTOOK: Flying illegals home would be 99.5 percent cheaper than Obamas plan
- Amid border crisis, Obama to take 15-day vacation in Martha's Vineyard
- GOP aims to sue Obama first over health care employer mandate
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world
Fighting in Iraq
World Cup's sexiest WAGs
U.S.-Ghana World Cup opener