- Mystery sign poster hits Washington state town: ‘It’s OK to say Merry Christmas’
- Pope Francis forms commission to advise on sex abuse
- Anthony Weiner on radio? Cumulus says, ‘Never, ever’
- Executive order: Obama ups green-energy mandate on feds to 20 percent
- GOP launches candidate training: How to talk to women
- N.Y.’s Rockefeller Center lights up, as Bloomberg flicks on 76-foot Christmas tree
- Northern Ireland turns to ‘Game of Thrones’ to draw in tourists
- Washington woman live-tweets husband’s horrific car death
- China City of America mulled for New York — with $65M tax dollars
- Yemen defense ministry rocked by suicide bomber, gunfire
Feds hide behind potential text message loophole in sunshine law
The researcher who exposed former EPA chief Lisa P. Jackson’s private email account is now taking aim at her potential successor — and is expanding the inquiry into the world of mobile phone text messages, which are shaping up as the next frontier in open-records legal battles.
Christopher Horner, the researcher, has requested some phone text message records from Gina McCarthy, An Environmental Protection Agency assistant administrator whom President Obama has tapped for the top job. Mr. Horner wants to see the texts Ms. McCarthy was sending during the days she appeared before Congress over the past four years.
Even more broadly, he is testing the limits of federal open-records laws by going after texts, which some analysts said could be a new loophole in the federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).
“No text messages have apparently ever been turned over by EPA in response to FOIA and congressional oversight requests for ‘records’ or ‘electronic records.’ Yet they are undeniably agency records under various relevant statutes,” Mr. Horner told The Washington Times. “Has EPA been destroying these records or preserving them as required, but merely hiding them from the public and from Congress?”
The EPA didn’t return messages Friday or Monday asking about its policy on storing or searching text messages, nor did the agency answer questions about Ms. McCarthy in particular, but documents on the agency’s website seem to suggest that employees are supposed to preserve their text messages.
The Obama administration overall doesn’t appear to have done much work on text messages and open records.
The White House budget office didn’t return messages seeking comment Friday or Monday. The Washington Times also reached out to a handful of departments Monday to ask about their text message open-records policies, but didn’t get an answer from any of them.
Even congressional champions of open-records laws don’t appear to have focused on the intersection between texts and FOIA.
The National Archives and Records Administration, which is responsible for preserving federal records, said it hasn’t issued any guidance and said the only texts that would fall under open-records preservation rules are those that constitute a “record” under the Federal Records Act.
For messages that are deemed “non-transitory federal records,” which means they must be preserved beyond 180 days, “agencies should take reasonable steps to preserve the text, including either forwarding to an email system, or memorializing in some other fashion (just like voice mails),” Chris Isleib, a spokesman for the National Archives, said in an email.
When it gets FOIA requests, the National Archives takes reasonable steps to find any records that would be responsive, including those on electronic media, Mr. Isleib said.
“My feeling is, any communication that would be a public record if done on paper ought to be a public record if done electronically and whatever preservation policies that existed for paper records ought to be at least as thorough for electronic preservation,” he said. “Unfortunately, what we already know is that people use technology to hide stuff.”
Mr. Bunting’s group is holding its annual conference in May, and he said one of the major focuses will be on what he called “digital sleight-of-hand” that officials are using to avoid scrutiny.
The EPA, in particular, has been the subject of complaints about its record-keeping.
© Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Stephen Dinan can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Medal of Honor case goes to 3rd defense secretary; Rep. Duncan Hunter says system broken
- John Boehner says blame for slow Congress lies with Democrats
- Hola: Boehner prepares to push amnesty bill through House
- Adios muchacho: Christie threatens veto of NJ's Dream Act
- Issa: FBI impeding inquiry into IRS targeting of conservative groups
Latest Blog Entries
- CURL: 'Mission Accomplished' for Obamacare
- American teacher shot and killed at Benghazi international school
- NAPOLITANO: Liberty, the wellspring of capitalism and charity
- 'Hunger Games' delivers Obama's message on income inequality
- Pentagon may give recruits 'a shot to start over' after shameful social media posts
- Democratic infighting erupts over 'we can have it all' fantasy on entitlements
- HARPER: 'Knockout game' not a myth to liberal Sharpton
- Obama returns to class warfare as poll numbers plunge
- Hack attack: 2 million Facebook, Twitter passwords stolen
- Inside the Ring: China targeting U.S. spy flights amid escalating tensions
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Find the latest news and happening that effect those in the Washington D.C., Northern Virginia and Maryland Metro region.
Television commentary, reviews, news and nonstop DVR catch-up by Lisa King Dolloff and friends.
The Constitution: Every issue, every time. No exceptions, no excuses. And how to get from here to there.
A libertarian look at breaking news and political trends by author Tom Mullen.