- The Washington Times - Wednesday, August 11, 2004

In the Old West, when law enforcement was spotty or nonexistent, vigilantes sometimes stepped in. A known cattle rustler might be found face-down in a gully with a terminal case of “lead poisoning,” as they said in TV Westerns.

Whatever purpose was served by vigilantism (a term derived from San Francisco’s Committee on Vigilance, formed by citizens in 1851 to combat organized crime) in such circumstances, it is a practice most Americans now find abhorrent, as it conjures visions of mob violence and lynching.

However, few would likely question that under the most extreme circumstances, it still has a place — for example, the action of passengers and crew on United Air Lines Flight 93 on September 11, 2001, who fought the hijackers and caused the plane to crash in Pennsylvania.

The enormous gray area between these two poles was brought to mind by airlines reporting would-be terrorists apparently have made dry runs of attacks on airplanes to provoke, test and analyze security measures.

There also was the July incident on a Northwest Airlines flight from Detroit to Los Angeles, in which a group of 14 Syrian musicians indulged in several hours of bizarre and terrifying behavior that passengers and member of the flight crew suspected was terrorism-related.

The Arab men loitered in small groups during the flight; made innumerable trips to the lavatories, often carrying a large paper bag that passed from hand to hand; and finally, as the plane made its final approach into Los Angeles, “suddenly, seven of the men stood up in unison” and walked to various parts of the plane, according to what a fellow passenger later wrote.

For the millions who fly regularly, this sort of incident, and the prospect of potential terrorists testing the vulnerability of airplane security, raises the questions of under what circumstances passengers should intervene and what they should do.

Tommy Hamilton, SWAT team commander for the police force at Dallas-Forth Worth airport, who has worked with air marshals, cautions against a rush to vigilantism and urges reliance on the professionals. “Federal air marshals have credentials and will identify themselves as soon as practical. It will be easy to see who they are. They will not identify themselves until after someone has identified themselves [sic] as a terrorist-hijacker.” (There were reportedly several air marshals on the Northwest Detroit-Los Angeles flight, but they remained incognito because the suspects did not do anything overtly illegal.)

However, if no air marshals are aboard (they are now assigned to only a small percentage of domestic flights), flight attendants and passengers are the first line of defense.

Passengers should obey the directions of the flight crew but they should be prepared, mentally and physically, to act. Like a basketball player getting ready for a jump ball, or a sprinter in the starting blocks, every able-bodied passenger needs to be ready to move, and to act definitively, not tentatively.

Experts feel it is unlikely terrorists would be able to get firearms or explosives on a plane. The need to rely on “softer” weapons puts them at a disadvantage against scores of passengers, who have plenty of potential, improvised weapons at hand: a hard kick in the knee (more likely to succeed than in the groin, according to experts); an elbow in the face or ribs; any sharp object in the eyes; a soda can torn in half yields a sharp edge; a computer cord or belt used as a garrote; an oxygen canister (in one or more of the overhead bins), metal coffee pot or wine bottle used as a club. (Go for the bridge of the nose or the temple, and swing for the fences.)

Don’t mess with us, pardner; we’ve got the drop on you.

Henry I. Miller is a physician and a fellow at the Hoover Institution.

Copyright © 2018 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide