Any reader with more than a cursory knowledge of intelligence has two choices with Robert Littell’s new novel, Legends (Overlook, $25.95, 386 pages). Toss it across the room into the discard box for the next library sale, or, if you prefer, push reality away for a few hours and enjoy an interesting if very fantastical read. I suggest the American language needs a new word to describe such books, and so I just made one up. Call Mr. Littell’s novel “spy-fi.”
Mr. Littell’s story involves a CIA operative who might or might not be named Martin Odum, who we meet in retirement (perhaps) working as a private detective in Brooklyn. In his agency career, Odum was also known as Dante Pippen, a bomb maker for the Irish Republican Army, and Lincoln Dittman, a Civil War expert. Each of these guises required a carefully crafted “legend” — that is real spookspeak for a cover story to mask an assumed identity.
And here is where I jump ship on Mr. Littell. In his telling, the mere assumption of a “legend” enables a CIA case officer to live and work in a variety of foreign environments with very dangerous people. Persons in the business suggest that field life ain’t that simple, to say the least. In any event, Mr. Littell does put his multipersonality character into a series of perilous situations, and you are required to do some mental scrambling when you face the possibility that the Civil War expert actually lived — or thinks he did, anyway — during that period and got to know such persons as Walt Whitman.
People were interested in these podcasts
But another bit of fantasy almost caused me to abandon my duty station in mid-read. Odum’s own CIA, in the person of the head of the Clandestine Services, is trying to have him killed to prevent him from revealing that the Agency masterminded the economic collapse of the Soviet Union. Here Mr. Littell hints at some reality that has yet to be fully explored, and had he stopped there, without once again using the shopworn device of turning CIA into a Murder, Inc., to borrow words from the late President Johnson, he would have had a more plausible story.
Now I used these pages a year or so ago to heap praise on Mr. Littell’s last book, “The Company,” and I find my words as a cover blurb on “Legends,” to wit: “… the Cold War might be over, but it still can produce good yarns.” Intelligence remains a field where what really happens can seldom be matched by even a novelist of the talents of Robert Littell.
• • •
That said, one means of producing good spy fiction is to graft a novel onto actual happenings in the world of intelligence. Such is the unique skill possessed by John Weisman, who gives us his third novel in three years that keenly tracks some things that have been happening out at Langley. It is Direct Action (William Morrow, $24.95, 355 pages).
Mr. Weisman is painful reading because much of what he describes actually happened in recent years at CIA commencing (more or less) with the regime of John Deutch as director of central intelligence during the Clinton years. Mr. Weisman describes how Mr. Deutch and his executive director, a woman named Nora Slatkin, essentially dismantled the CIA’s Clandestine Services, driving away “more than 240 experienced case officers — 40 percent of those with more than 15 years of field experience.”
The few who remained found themselves forbidden to have contacts with anyone who had been engaged in any type of criminal or terrorist activity. Guess what happened? CIA was caught blindfolded on September 11.
Mr. Weisman’s story is how a former case officer, now working for a private contractor, sets out to find and … ahem, neutralize … a bombmaker who is planning simultaneous attacks against the United States and other Western countries. Suffice to say that this operative is not bound by Deutch-era strictures.
As in his previous works — he has written more than a dozen novels, incuding the Rogue Warrior series of bestsellers — Mr. Weisman has the knack of producing as-it-really-is prose. In effect, he is writing an in-progress history of the modern CIA that goes a long ways towards explaining why it is now so dysfunctional.
• • •
I must use a shoehorn to fit this book into a piece about spy fiction, but do bear with me for a moment. In 1975-6, reports circulated among Western military attaches assigned to Moscow about a Soviet naval officer who commandeered a destroyer, the Storozhevay, and tried to flee to another country. A massive fleet and air mobilization was required to track him down in the Baltic. The officer, Valery Sablyn, was executed. The Soviets, understandably, did their best to suppress the story of the mutiny.
In 1981, an American naval officer named Gregory D. Young decided to piece the story together while a student at the Naval Postgraduate School. Drawing upon emigre reports and scattered news accounts, he wrote a thesis, “Mutiny on the Storozhevay: A Case Study of Dissent in the Soviet Navy.” The paper found its way to the Naval Academy Library in Annapolis.
Now, the connect: In 1982, a young insurance salesman in southern Maryland named Tom Clancy was seeking a more interesting way to make a living. He chanced upon Mr. Young’s paper, they corresponded, Mr. Clancy did some work on his own, and he published “The Hunt for Red October,” a much-fictionalized account of the mutiny that was the first of his many bestsellers.
Now the true story is told by Young and Nate Braden in The Last Sentry: The True Story That Inspired The Hunt for Red October (Naval Institute, $28.95, 250 pages).
In real life, Sablyn sought to flee to protest what he felt was an endangering of the communist system by Premier Leonid Brezhnev and his circle. Mr. Clancy shifted the action to a submarine rather than a destroyer and had the skipper defecting to the West, rather than protesting betrayal of red ideology.
Mr. Young and Mr. Braden did commendable detective work in finding and interviewing members of Sablyn’s family who explained the depth of his discontent. They also obtained Soviet documents pertaining to his trial and execution, as well as a lengthy KGB report on the episode. Not a novel, to be sure, but a well-told account of what happened during the Soviet military during the period when the Evil Empire was headed for a crack up.
Joseph C. Goulden is writing a book on Cold War intelligence. His e-mail is JosephG894@aol.com.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.