Former FBI Director James Comey and Deputy Director Andrew McCabe, former CIA Director John Brennan and former Director of National Intelligence James Clapper have lots of things in common.
One, they ran the nation’s key intelligence and investigatory agencies under former President Barack Obama. They were deeply involved in the “Russian collusion” hoax. And they participated in the surveillance of the Trump campaign and transition.
Mr. Comey and Mr. McCabe both signed applications for Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court warrants requesting surveillance on Trump campaign aide Carter Page. A report by Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz criticized Mr. Comey and Mr. McCabe’s FBI for falsehoods and misrepresentations during its investigation of the Donald Trump campaign.
Mr. Clapper, Mr. Brennan and the FBI helped to disseminate the fallacious Steele dossier to the press and among government agencies.
Two, Mr. Comey, Mr. McCabe, Mr. Brennan and Mr. Clapper have all lied either under oath or in the public sphere.
Mr. Horowitz has said that he referred Mr. Comey for criminal prosecution for leaking classified memos he wrote about his confidential conversations with the president, but the Justice Department did not pursue charges. He signed FISA warrant applications that the inspector general has determined were misleading at best and at worst simply flat-out wrong.
In testimony before the House Judiciary and oversight committees, there were 245 occasions on which Mr. Comey claimed he couldn’t remember details or couldn’t answer questions.
Mr. Comey did not tell the truth when he said the Steele dossier was not the prime evidence that he submitted to the FISA court. He also lied about when he was briefed on the dossier.
Mr. McCabe was given a criminal referral for lying to federal investigators. His story about conspiring to catch Mr. Trump on tape in an effort to remove him under the 25th Amendment cannot be reconciled with the version of the account told by his apparent partner in that gambit, former Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein.
Mr. Brennan has on two occasions lied under oath to Congress, first about collateral deaths caused by drone strikes abroad, then about CIA spying on Senate staffers’ computers. Mr. Clapper got caught lying about the surveillance of U.S. citizens and claimed he gave the “least untruthful” answer. Both have given accounts of their knowledge of the Steele dossier that are contradicted by a number of sources. Mr. Clapper falsely claimed of the dossier that “more and more of it has been corroborated.”
Three, all four of these former intelligence chiefs detest the president of the United States.
Mr. Comey has compared Mr. Trump to a mafia don and stated that he is morally unfit to be president. Mr. McCabe, who was likewise fired from the FBI, has called Mr. Trump’s behavior “disgusting.” Mr. Clapper said that Mr. Trump may be working with Vladimir Putin as a Russian “asset.” Mr. Brennan called Mr. Trump a “disgraced demagogue” as well as venal, corrupt and amoral.
Four, all in their post-Obama administration careers are either paid cable news analysts or frequent guest commentators. Mr. Clapper is a CNN security analyst. Mr. Brennan was hired by MSNBC for a similar role. Mr. McCabe is a CNN contributor. Mr. Comey often makes guest appearances on news programs as a political and intelligence expert.
In the most controversial stories, Mr. Brennan, Mr. Clapper and Mr. McCabe are being paid to analyze theories, facts and findings in which they themselves are often central players. As a guest commentator, Mr. Comey has weighed in on these controversies even as he distorts his past roles in them.
Yet such abject conflicts of interest are not the only ethical problems posed by these four. Until recently, all four held federal security clearances. Mr. Comey recently gave his up, apparently so he would not have to give testimony about classified information in the Horowitz investigation. The former intelligence officials sometimes gave us wink-and-nod suggestions that their television expertise was based on information not available to the general public.
In sum, we are witnessing a surreal collusion between the nation’s former top intelligence officials and the progressive media — beyond even the nightmares of so-called conspiracy theorists.
The most powerful intelligence chiefs of the Obama administration — Messrs. Brennan, Clapper, Comey and McCabe — have routinely offered the nation their own warped theories about wrongdoing in high places that are as self-serving as they are contradicted by facts.
The conclusions of both the Mueller investigation and the Horowitz report are damning to the past analyses of all four.
In the advocacy culture of our new media, ex-government officials such as Mr. Brennan, Mr. Clapper and Mr. McCabe can be paid to appear on news programs to analyze (or vindicate) their own unethical behavior.
As employees of the media, they sell their checkered government service to exonerate themselves while confirming the anti-Trump biases of their paying hosts.
• Victor Davis Hanson, a classicist and historian at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University, is the author of “The Second World Wars: How the First Global Conflict Was Fought and Won” (Basic Books, 2017).