- - Tuesday, April 6, 2021

In the aftermath of the 2020 election, 64% of Americans support strengthening election safeguards to ensure our elections are free and fair.

But right now, Democrats are winning the messaging war. The irony is that the American people are on the same side as Republicans. Voters want real election reform and want to feel confident that our elections are secure. What voters do not want are the policies included in H.R. 1 and the Senate’s version of the bill, S. 1.

The so-called For the People Act would be disastrous for this country and do nothing to restore Americans’ faith in our elections. Instead, the bill would widen the political divide by forcing a range of flawed policies on states that don’t want or need them.

The bill allows taxpayer money to be used to fund political campaigns, virtually abolishes voter ID laws, undermines our First Amendment rights and forbids anonymous speech. The legislation even is a direct attack on federalism, as Washington would control elections instead of the states.

But new polling from the National Republican Senate Committee (NRSC) finds that these ideas are wildly unpopular with the American people and can provide key insights into how Republicans can win the messaging war on election reform.

First off, it is important that Republicans highlight how H.R. 1 would make all federal elections funded by tax dollars. In total, 56% of likely voters strongly disagreed/somewhat disagreed that elections should be funded with taxpayer dollars. Only 31% strongly agreed/somewhat agreed.

It is not surprising that voters don’t want their taxpayer dollars to fund candidates they disagree with, including all those annoying attack ads on TV or online. The American people know there are better ways to spend their hard-earned tax dollars.

Democrats try to explain this away by claiming the funding will come from new corporate penalties. However, this money is still coming from the same general pool of funds and should be spent on roads and schools, not political consultants.

Another policy in H.R. 1 that Republicans should highlight is that the legislation would virtually abolish voter identification laws by forcing states to accept the ballots of voters who don’t have the necessary identification. 

Voter ID requirements are widely popular, as 72% of likely voters are very concerned/somewhat concerned when asked about states not requiring a photo ID when one requests an absentee ballot. Overall, a majority of Republicans, Democrats and independents support voter ID laws.

But you wouldn’t know that from Democrats. When Republicans push for voter ID laws, they get falsely called racist and accused of disenfranchising voters.

The reality is that nothing could be further from the truth as these laws are about securing our elections and increasing transparency, not suppressing the vote. Study after study has found that voter ID laws don’t reduce turnout or otherwise suppress the vote.

And lastly, Republicans must emphasize that H.R. 1 would force states to mail ballots to every registered voter, even if they didn’t request it. This change could lead to thousands of ballots being sent to the wrong address or stolen from mailboxes of those unaware that they were getting a mail ballot.

It seems like commonsense that a voter must request an absentee ballot to get one, but H.R. 1 flips this logic on its head. Flooding America with unneeded ballots creates vulnerabilities fraudsters could use to cast fake votes.

Voters are skeptical of this provision, as the idea of universal mail-in voting is very unpopular with voters. Seventy-one percent surveyed said they were very concerned/somewhat concerned by the practice.

The good news is that it is not too late for Republicans to win the messaging war on H.R. 1 and ensure all our future elections are free and fair. More than anything, Republicans need to go on the offensive and explain why H.R. 1 shouldn’t be passed.

Last week, Club for Growth launched digital ads in West Virginia and Arizona urging voters to call Sens. Joe Manchin, West Virginia Democrat, and Kyrsten Sinema, Arizona Democrat, and tell them to vote no on H.R. 1.

It looks like the strategy is working, as Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, New York Democrat, signaled that the vote might not happen until mid-April, suggesting that Democrats don’t currently have the votes.

Voters already agree with Republicans on the need for election reform and that the policies in H.R. 1 would set our country backwards. Conservatives just have to do a better job at messaging our cause to the American people.

• David McIntosh is the president of Club for Growth.

Sign up for Daily Opinion Newsletter

Manage Newsletters

Copyright © 2021 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide