Top homeland security and intelligence officials told Congress on Wednesday that their experts have found no evidence of rogue AI agents or a foreign government lurking behind the current spate of outages ranging from the air-traffic control system to banks.
Instead, they blamed the fast pace of changes in computer applications, and said the outages were the natural result of patches and updates. And they said to expect the breakdowns to keep occurring.
“We have no indication that these incidents are related, that they’re coordinated. We also have no indication they are the result of a state-sponsored malign actor,” Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton told the House Homeland Security Committee.
People were interested in these podcasts
DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin, who oversees cybersecurity, said they haven’t even found any evidence that would link the outages to one another — much less to an adversary.
He put the likelihood that an opposing force was behind the problems at just 2%.
The high-profile outages began last week when some of Microsoft’s applications went down. Then came the full air traffic ground stop, for only the second time since the 2001 terrorist attacks.
Scattered outages in banking applications and other online services left many Americans — and members of Congress — drawing other conclusions.
Egged on by suspicious constituents, members of both parties said the confluence of outages was too much to be a coincidence.
“What the hell is going on?” said Rep. Shri Thanedar, Michigan Democrat.
Mr. Clayton said the government’s best analysis right now is that systems went down as part of routine maintenance, such as software patches and upgrades.
He analogized it to employees being told by their company that their systems will go down for several hours late on a weekend night.
“We are in an environment where the rate of patching, the rate of upgrading of systems is increasing. That is the result of advancements in compute and in applications,” he said.
The worrying outages hit Microsoft, with disruptions to its Outlook email and calendar system that is relied upon by firms and employees worldwide. Then came the airplane ground stop, which upended thousands of flights.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has said work to upgrade digital traffic routers may have been the cause of the flight issue.
Some high-profile financial companies had some service outages this week after what was labeled a “software bug” at J.P. Morgan Chase.
Then the National Security Agency had an internal classified network go down on Tuesday. The snooping agency said it was performing “routine maintenance.”
The confluence was too much for some lawmakers, but the Trump officials said it was indeed coincidence.
Mr. Mullin said he was “98% confident that this has nothing to do with our adversaries.”
Deputy FBI Director Christopher Raia said they are still looking for those links, but he agreed with the secretary’s evaluation.
“Our cyber experts are out on scene with a lot of these companies,” he said. “We have seen no malicious activity as of today.”
They were testifying to the House Homeland Security Committee, in a contentious hearing that likely previewed how Democrats will approach senior Trump officials when they take control of Congress in the new year.
“You are killing people,” Rep. LaMonica McIver, New Jersey Democrat, told Mr. Mullin, pointing to the rising number of deaths of migrant detainees in the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Rep. Delia Ramirez, Illinois Democrat, who serves on investigative subcommittees for two separate committees, told Mr. Mullin to get comfortable in the witness chair.
“You are going to spend a lot of time in that seat. I will be bringing to you and your staff questions to be answered,” she said.
Mr. Mullin gave back just as good. To Ms. McIver, he pointed out that the standards of care in ICE detention are better than the care delivered to inmates at prisons in her own state of New Jersey.
And he was merciless to Democrats who missed most of the hearing then came in to ask questions — often ones that Mr. Mullin had already answered to other colleagues.
Rep. Al Green finally had enough, and explained why he didn’t want to be in the room any longer than necessary.
“Quite frankly, I don’t enjoy being in his company,” the Texas Democrat said, adding, “You ought to be arrested.”
Mr. Mullin responded by chiding Mr. Green, who lost his primary earlier this year to a fellow Democrat: “Hope you enjoy your forced retirement.”

Please read our comment policy before commenting.