Public schools that allow teachers and staff to carry firearms have been remarkably free of gun attacks, particularly compared with those without any armed presence, according to a study released Thursday.
John R. Lott Jr., head of the Crime Prevention Research Center, crunched the numbers from 2000 to 2025 and could not find any mass shootings in schools that allow firearms. In fact, he could not find any instances of a shooting-related death or injury during or near school hours in buildings where staff are allowed to be armed.
That included attacks and accidental discharges.
People were interested in these podcasts
He did find one suicide, in 2001, by a student who brought his own gun, and he identified one teacher who was injured in 2014 when her gun discharged in a bathroom and porcelain fragments from a toilet struck her.
Mr. Lott found zero cases of a student taking a teacher’s or staff member’s gun and harming someone.
Those schools had a better record than those that bar firearms — and a far better record than those patrolled by police or paid security guards.
The data challenges a major concern of gun control advocates who warn that more guns in school mean more shootings.
“We don’t need to guess. We have decades of experience with many thousands of schools that have this right now. With all of the experience you have, you can’t point to any problems — I think it’s pretty startling,” Mr. Lott told The Washington Times.
He said the record for schools that allow staff to be armed looks even better compared with the other options.
Schools that have official security — a police officer or paid guard — account for about 45% of the country’s total. Mr. Lott found 39 attacks with casualties at those schools during the years he studied.
The third option — schools that prohibit any firearm-carrying presence — accounts for about 42% of schools. They fared the worst in Mr. Lott’s data, with 551 incidents with casualties.
Mr. Lott said he found 20 cases of officers accidentally discharging their guns, six cases of accidental discharge by a private security guard and two cases when security officers’ guns fired during a struggle.
In one case, a student took a school resource officer’s pistol and accidentally fired it, underscoring wider mishaps involving security personnel.
Mr. Lott also identified three instances in which police shot someone other than the intended target, or perhaps misidentified a bystander as a threat.
“When you look at this, they just don’t occur. There’s not one case where a teacher has either accidentally or on purpose, out of rage, shot somebody. There’s no case where a student has gotten ahold of a gun and done something bad,” he said.
The idea of armed teachers and other staff gained steam after the 1999 massacre at Columbine High School in Colorado and again after the 2012 shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut.
A 2018 report by the Federal Commission on School Safety also pushed the idea and urged schools to “seriously consider” training and arming faculty and staff.
Gun control groups and national Democratic lawmakers have opposed arming faculty and staff.
Everytown for Gun Safety said on its website that teachers cannot be expected to make a good decision “in a moment of extreme duress and confusion.”
“The notion of a highly trained teacher armed with a gun, able to respond as quickly as trained law enforcement, is a myth,” Everytown argued.
Giffords, a gun control group founded by former Rep. Gabrielle Giffords of Arizona, conducted its own report in 2021 cataloging dozens of instances involving guns brought to school by a teacher, staff member, parent, police officer or security guard. The report, which covered 2014 to 2021, did not distinguish between those authorized to have guns and those who were not.
Incidents included guns misplaced or found by students, accidental discharges, brandishing during an argument and suicides.
One teacher’s gun fell out of his waistband while he was helping elementary school children do cartwheels, but no shots were fired.
During a 2019 incident in Alabama, a substitute teacher’s gun went off in a first-grade classroom. A student reportedly went to the nurse’s office after being struck by a fragment. The teacher was not authorized to carry the gun, according to the news account.
“Arming teachers is an incredibly unpopular proposition, opposed by seven out of 10 teenagers, eight out of 10 teachers, and seven out of 10 parents. And for good reason,” the Giffords group concluded.
Mr. Lott’s study gathered school lockdown and shooting reports from 2000 to 2025, using multiple databases. He and his fellow researchers identified 1,057 cases of gunshots on school property, including accidents, suicides and gang shootings.
Researchers then tried to determine whether the school was covered by a staff firearm policy, had a police officer or some form of official security, or did not knowingly allow guns on the property.
The rate of campus shooting deaths has trended upward over the quarter century covered by the study. In the early years, deaths generally hovered at or below 12. In the 2020s, however, they have ranged from 18 to 51 per year.
The deadliest year in the data was 2018, for which researchers identified 52 deaths.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.