The House is expected to take up a Senate-passed permitting overhaul bill next month without making additional changes, putting on-the-fence lawmakers — mainly Democrats — in a tough spot.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA for short, updates several existing laws to streamline federal reviews and approvals needed to build major projects across the U.S. One of the primary goals of the legislation is to speed up domestic energy development and lower costs for consumers.
The Senate passed the bill late Thursday, 62-33, but without some last-minute changes both parties had negotiated.
People were interested in these podcasts
The House has an opportunity to add those provisions, but appears unlikely to do so because it would send the measure back to the Senate with only a few weeks left in the year to get the bill to President Trump’s desk for his promised signature.
“This critical legislation will cut red tape, create jobs, and lower costs for families,” House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, Louisiana Republican, said on social media Friday. “It is more important now than ever that the House passes this permitting reform bill to the President. Now is the time to finish the job.”
Mr. Trump praised the Senate passage of the “landmark permitting reform legislation” during a press conference Friday.
“It’s a big deal,” he said. “Now it goes to the House, and if passed, it’s projected to put at least $1,300 a year back in the pockets of hardworking Americans. But it’s even beyond that. It’s going to cause tremendous amounts of new building to go along with already the record … numbers of jobs in construction.”
The White House Council of Economic Advisers estimates the measure will result in $82 billion to $164 billion in additional economic output each year. For the average household, that will translate to wage increases of $306 to $637 and electric bills that are $178 to $251 lower.
Lawmakers have been working for years to overhaul the federal permitting process, and BAAJA is the most substantive product offered to date that has a shot at becoming law.
But it still has its detractors in both parties: Democrats who say it goes too far in curbing environmental and preservation reviews, and Republicans concerned about an over-concentration of federal power.
The bill, which was negotiated before the midterm elections, has divided Democrats in both chambers.
Some Democrats say they should wait until their party takes control of the House and Senate next year to negotiate a better permitting deal. Others argue Mr. Trump may not be willing to renegotiate and they should take what they can get now and work toward improvements later.
“BAAJA lowers costs and lowers emissions. It’s that simple,” Rep. Scott Peters, California Democrat, said in a statement. “It’s unimaginable that after this month’s election, when the entire country demanded lower costs, we would whiff on the opportunity right in front of us.”
Rep. Melanie Stansbury, New Mexico Democrat, said she opposes the bill because it undermines tribal sovereignty, undercuts environmental laws and “locks in dangerous oil and gas and mining projects that could threaten sacred sites.”
“We appreciate the work that has gone into making this bill better, but this is not the bill, this is not the time and this not what the American people asked for,” she said in a floor speech.
Democratic opponents also said they are skeptical that renewable energy projects the legislation is supposed to help accelerate will get a fair shake under the Trump administration.
Mr. Trump has said that he would still not green-light wind energy projects, saying that “wind turbines are a major loser.”
House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries of New York has spoken vaguely about issues that need to be addressed before the permitting bill advances. His office did not return a request for comment on Friday.
Only 15 of 47 Senate Democrats voted for BAAJA, a lower number of supporters than expected after a bipartisan push for changes faltered.
Senate negotiators had agreed to allow a combined 19 amendments from the two parties, including a manager’s amendment addressing the most sweeping concerns, but could not get unanimous consent from all 100 senators to hold those votes.
The agreement on other amendment votes was blocked by Sens. Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden, Oregon Democrats, because their amendments seeking additional restrictions to data center development were excluded.
“There is enormous concern that this bill puts the pedal to the floor on data centers across the country, right after an election in which data centers were an enormously sensitive issue,” Mr. Merkley said.
The move angered other Democrats whose proposed changes were included in the manager’s amendment that would have been adopted. Sen. Ruben Gallego, Arizona Democrat, on social media accused Mr. Merkley of blocking the improvements in an effort to make the bill “so unpopular that it will die in the House.”
Senate Energy and Natural Resources Chairman Mike Lee, Utah Republican and one of the lead negotiators of BAAJA, said Mr. Wyden’s amendment to ban data centers from being built on federal land was poorly crafted.
“It defined ’data center’ so broadly that it could include something as simple as a server rack inside of a closet with some computers in it,” he said, noting the ban would have applied to the White House complex and prohibited installation of telecommunications equipment and servers that are critical for national security.
The bill that passed does deal with one concern about data centers, with a provision requiring utility regulators to force large data centers to pay for their own electricity demand and any grid upgrades needed to accommodate that.
Mr. Lee and the other Senate negotiators of BAAJA said they were disappointed their manager’s amendment making changes to the bill sought by both parties was blocked but that it is best for the House to pass the bill without changes given the limited time left in the current Congress.
“There are things that we can do to add the provisions of the manager’s amendment to another bill, another must-pass vehicle, or perhaps even pass it as a standalone,” Mr. Lee said.
Senate Environment and Public Works Chairwoman Shelley Moore Capito, West Virginia Republican, said an attempt to add the manager’s amendment in the House could “create more problems” with members there who will want to negotiate additional changes.
Her Democratic counterpart, Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, said they are “working on” alternative methods to passing the manager’s amendment and that he is confident the Senate-passed bill can clear the House.
“It has a very significant number of Democratic House members who ardently support it,” Mr. Whitehouse said.
A significant block of those supporters are part of the centrist, business friendly New Democrat Coalition, whose leaders have endorsed the bill. But they also put out a statement Friday saying they “will look for opportunities to negotiate changes that reflect environmental and tribal concerns” as the bill heads to the House.
Mr. Peters was one of the leaders who cosigned that statement, but in his solo statement he said the effort to address the issues left on the table when the Senate amendments were blocked should not involve reopening the Senate-passed bill.
“We should make sure this bill gets across the finish line to lower costs and emissions and then continue our work to make the progress they opposed, and more,” he said.
The level of Democratic support the bill can get without changes matters because Republican leaders are likely to want to bring it to the floor under suspension of the rules, which requires two-thirds support for passage.
Republicans are having post-election attendance issues that are making it difficult for them to clear a rule needed to bring bills to the floor for a simple-majority vote.
House Speaker Mike Johnson, Louisiana Republican, cited the permitting bill among the year-end priorities he wants to get done in a letter Friday urging Republicans to show up to work after Thanksgiving.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.