In a recent op-ed in this publication, deputy commentary editor Anath Hartmann makes a reasonable argument that the United States should act decisively to finish off Iran (“Iran attacks again. Trump must finish the job,” Web, Nov. 16).

I concur with the sentiment. Unfortunately, our military leadership does not have a clue how to do it other than to prepare another target list.

President Trump has yet to articulate a clear, desired end state. Our adversaries have read him like a book. They believe that they can take whatever he is willing throw at them through bombing alone. They see no downside to waiting us out. So far, they have been right.

People were interested in these podcasts

There were three roads not taken at the outset of the war — and they might have ended it on terms favorable to us, in a timely manner. The first and most radical would have been to irradiate the three main nuclear development sites to make them unusable for years, if not decades.

My guess is that such an approach was never seriously considered because of our avowed promise policy of not making first use of weapons of mass destruction.

A second option would have been to use information dominance and discriminate airpower to enable the Iranian people to overthrow the government. Through a combination of drone loudspeakers, radio announcements and loitering missile-armed drones, we could have eradicated Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) troops trying to suppress the uprising.

A third option might have been to seize Iran’s Kharg Island by amphibious assault to use it as a bargaining chip in negotiations, since it is vital to the Iranian economy. The problem is that we no longer have the capability to launch such an operation.

Seven years ago, the then U.S. Marine Corps commandant got rid of all of the tanks, obstacle breaching equipment and bridging units that would have been needed to conduct the assault. He believed such operations were no longer possible.

Central Command could have assigned tank and engineer units to a Marine amphibious brigade (MEB) and cross-trained them for amphibious operations. That ship has sailed. As Mike Tyson famously said, “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.” In this case, I am not sure we had much of a plan to begin with.

GARY ANDERSON

Daytona Beach Shores, Florida

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.