OPINION:
The debate over American military aid to Israel has narrowed to one question: Has Israel’s economy grown enough to absorb the aid’s end, gradual or immediate? But the discussion leaves out much of the ledger.
First are the benefits that America draws from the relationship, which partly offset the aid but cannot be converted into dollars. These include combat feedback that helps improve American-made aircraft and weapons; intelligence on Iran, terrorism and proliferation; missile defense; access to the ports of Haifa and Ashdod and to Israeli airfields for American refueling and cargo aircraft; and an ally that has never asked American troops to defend it.
Second, let us recall assets given up under U.S. pressure. In the defensive Six Day War of 1967, Israel took the Sinai oilfields of Abu Rudeis, Ras Sudr and Alma. Under American-brokered agreements and direct presidential pressure, Israel relinquished the oilfields, which together equaled about three-quarters of its crude oil needs.
People were interested in these podcasts
Aid was not explicitly designed to replace that oil, but the arithmetic is striking. At each year’s prices, the oil would have been worth roughly 17% to 30% percent of all American aid since 1976 if output declined as fields mature, and more than half if it had held steady.
Against roughly $170 billion in aid, that is $30 billion to $45 billion on the cautious assumption and over $100 billion on the generous one, before extraction costs.
Israel’s share of replacing its two Sinai air bases, beyond America’s $800 million grant, equaled between 20% and 60% of a year’s military aid then, a rounding error against $170 billion. And in 2022, Israel ceded the Qana gas prospect to Lebanon under pressure from the Biden administration.
As luck would have it, it turned out to be worthless: TotalEnergies found no commercially viable gas.
As aid ends, two cautions apply. American geopolitical demands will not end with it — and Israel will bear the costs alone. And Egypt still receives about $1.3 billion a year in American military financing, while other regional states are buying advanced American weapons, including a proposed $24.3 billion sale of F-35s to Saudi Arabia.
Israel can presently afford life without military aid. The debate should go on, but with the whole ledger in view.
JULIO MESSER
New York, New York

Please read our comment policy before commenting.