- ‘Welcome to the edge of freedom’: Biden’s boots touch down in DMZ
- Obama: Hole U.S. ‘digging out of’ requires billions more in unemployment benefits
- Obama’s regulatory agenda will cost U.S. economy $143B next year: report
- Patriot Act author on James Clapper: Fire, prosecute him
- Russia P.M. Medvedev: No amnesty for political prisoners
- Michigan GOP Senate hopeful reminds government is the ‘servant’
- Christmas, by Congress: Members mull a 15-cent tax on trees
- U.S. unemployment falls to five-year low of 7 percent; 203K jobs added
- World mourns Nelson Mandela and celebrates his life; burial set for Dec. 15
- Bill O’Reilly reminds: Nelson Mandela ‘was a communist’
Churchill loses appeal of university firing
Said 9/11 victims like Eichman, but other causes cited for job loss
DENVER | Former University of Colorado professor Ward Churchill won't be returning to the classroom anytime soon after losing his appeal Wednesday to get his job back.
The Colorado Court of Appeals upheld a lower-court decision holding that the CU Board of Regents was entitled to "quasi-judicial immunity" when it voted to fire Mr. Churchill in 2007 on grounds of academic misconduct.
"We conclude that the nature of the decision reached by the University and its Regents, and the process by which that decision was reached, shared enough characteristics with the judicial process to warrant absolute immunity from liability," Judge Dennis Graham wrote in the 64-page opinion.
The ruling also rejected Mr. Churchill's contention that the university's two-year investigation into his academic writings and research constituted an "adverse employment action" against him.
Churchill attorney David Lane blasted the opinion, calling it a "rubber stamp" of the lower-court decision. He also said he plans to appeal the case to the Colorado Supreme Court and, if necessary, the U.S. Supreme Court.
"It's an unfortunate fact of life that our most cherished freedoms are in the hands of politicians and bureaucrats in black robes," Mr. Lane said.
He added that the appellate court "almost asks for the Supreme Court to take on the case," citing a paragraph in the opinion acknowledging that the high court has yet to offer a definitive ruling on what constitutes an adverse employment action.
The appellate opinion states, "We perceive no error in the trial court's ruling because Churchill did not establish that the University's investigation constituted an adverse employment action. Whether an investigation alone is sufficient to constitute an adverse employment action has not been resolved by the United States Supreme Court, and there does not appear to be a definitive consensus on the matter among federal courts."
Mr. Churchill drew national scorn in 2005 for his essay comparing victims of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks to Nazi war criminal Adolf Eichmann. At the time, Mr. Churchill was a tenured professor of ethnic studies and the department chairman.
A university investigation concluded that the essay was protected by the First Amendment but also charged him with plagiarism, falsifying data and fabricating evidence in some of his other writings and research.
The board dismissed Mr. Churchill by an 8-1 vote after a series of faculty investigations found him guilty of academic misconduct. Mr. Churchill filed a lawsuit against the university saying he was fired in retaliation for the essay and that the investigations were nothing more than a witch hunt designed to provide cover.
A Denver jury decided in Mr. Churchill's favor in April 2009 but awarded him just $1 in symbolic damages. Trial Judge Larry J. Naves later vacated his jury's ruling, finding that the board had quasi-judicial immunity from lawsuits, and denied Mr. Churchill's request for reinstatement.
Board of Regents spokesman Ken McConnellogue said the university was "pleased with the result, and it confirms what we've contended all along."
As for Mr. Lane's intention to bring the case to the state Supreme Court, "we really expected he would do that," Mr. McConnellogue said.
"We'll cross that bridge if the court agrees to hear it," he said. "I really feel this ruling and the lower court ruling bodes well for the university."
Since his dismissal, the 63-year-old Mr. Churchill has stayed busy writing, traveling and making speeches, often to university audiences. A number of free-speech and university groups, including the American Civil Liberties Union and American Association of University Professors, have supported his legal challenges.
© Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Valerie Richardson covers politics and the West from Denver. She can be reached at email@example.com.
- Colorado judge: Bakery owner discriminated against gay couple
- Fast-food protests spur backlash
- 'Hunger Games' delivers Obama's message on income inequality
- Gay couple's complaint against Colo. baker gets hearing
- Fracking supporters fire back at 'woefully misinformed' celebrities
Latest Blog Entries
- Bill OReilly reminds: Nelson Mandela was a communist
- Spike in battlefield deaths linked to restrictive rules of engagement
- Obama administration issues permits for wind farms to kill more eagles
- Obama: Hole U.S. 'digging out of' requires billions more in unemployment benefits
- Craigslist killers: Police say newlyweds stabbed man for thrills
- 'Dude, I'm dreading that I will have to go': Czech prime minister on Mandela funeral
- Kill team: Obama war chiefs widen drone death zones
- Rush Limbaugh: Obama trying to make Mandela death about himself
- NAPOLITANO: Pope Francis should be saving souls, not pocketbooks
- John Boehner says GOP should support gay candidates: I do
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Find the latest news and happening that effect those in the Washington D.C., Northern Virginia and Maryland Metro region.
A stat-head’s outlook, direct from his worn in couch cushion.
Classical music and the performing arts: news and reviews you can use.
Covering the world of soccer, including the World Cup, Major League Soccer, D.C. United and the English Premier League and other interesting sporting events.
White House pets gone wild!