- Jeffrey Corzine, son of ex-N.J. governor, dead at 31
- Australian surfing magazine sorry for calling indigenous surfer ‘apeish’
- Records: Man in Fla. theater shooting also was texting
- The Putin problem: U.S. needs Russian rockets for spy satellites
- Florida cops ticket toddler in toy convertible: report
- Kerry warns of ‘very serious’ response to Crimea-Russia alliance
- Fla. Rep. Alan Grayson’s wife drops restraining order against him
- McDonald’s lawsuits filed over wages ‘stolen’ like Hamburglar steals Big Macs
- HUMPHRIES: Fight like a Democrat – An open letter to Sen. Mitch McConnell
- Florida board member shocks with ‘Heil Hitler’ salute at town meeting
PIPES: Dueling fatwas
War comes home in the Internet era
The topic opens with “South Park,” an iconoclastic adult cartoon program on Comedy Central, which in April mocked the prohibition on depicting the Islamic Prophet Muhammad. An obscure website, RevolutionMuslim.com (whose proprietor subsequently was arrested on terrorism-related charges) responded by threatening the show’s writers, Trey Parker and Matt Stone. Panicked, Comedy Central censored further mention of Muhammad.
Enter Molly Norris, a cartoonist at the Seattle Weekly, who showed solidarity with Mr. Parker and Mr. Stone by posting a facetious “Everyone Draw Muhammad Day” appeal on Facebook, hoping that host of caricaturists would “counter Comedy Central’s message about feeling afraid.” To Ms. Norris‘ surprise, dismay and confusion, others took her idea seriously, prompting Facebook campaigns for and against her “day” and causing the Pakistani government temporarily to block Facebook. Ms. Norris disowned her initiative, apologized for it and even befriended the local Council on American-Islamic Relations representative, to little avail.
Anwar al-Awlaki, an Islamist leader in Yemen, responded in July by issuing a death sentence on Ms. Norris, inaccurately but pungently called a fatwa. On consulting with the police, Ms. Norris in September not only went underground but “went ghost” and disappeared entirely, including her name and her profession.
Mr. Awlaki was born in New Mexico in 1971 to well-connected Muslim Yemeni parents. His father, Nasser, studied and worked in the United States until 1978, when the family returned to Yemen. Anwar went to the United States as a student in 1991 and spent the next decade in various degree programs (engineering, education) only to emerge as an al Qaeda-style Islamist figure, comparable to Osama bin Laden in both his ideological fanaticism and his operational involvement in terrorism. Arrested in connection with the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, he inexplicably was released and allowed to move to a remote region of Yemen, beyond government control, where he currently lives.
U.S. law enforcement connects Mr. Awlaki to several violent attacks on Americans, including the Fort Hood shootings, the attempted bombing of a Northwest flight approaching Detroit and the Times Square bombing attempt. Mr. Awlaki’s terrorist record earned him a unique distinction: In April, for the first time in the nearly 250-year history of the United States, the government placed him on a “kill list,” making him the only U.S. citizen to be condemned to death by his own government without benefit of a legal process. Both the military and the intelligence services are targeting him; as one unnamed official puts it, he’s “in everybody’s sights.”
In response, in August his father initiated, with help from the American Civil Liberties Union and the Center for Constitutional Rights, a lawsuit against the U.S. government that challenges the targeting of Mr. Awlaki as illegal.
This extraordinary trading of fatwas prompts several observations.
First, Ms. Norris and all Americans currently live under the “Rushdie Rules,” which punish whoever disrespects Islam, Muhammad or the Koran. Make fun of Muhammad, and you’re on your own. Local and national politicians had nothing to say about Ms. Norris‘ plight. Journalists, usually keen to protect one of their own, went silent. No organization sprang up to raise money for her protection.
Second, the Internet stands at the heart of this entire episode. It turned Ms. Norris‘ jokey idea into an international incident, brought news of it to Mr. Awlaki in remote Yemen and enabled him to direct his American operatives. A mere 20 years ago, none of this could have taken place.
Third, the Internet and Islamism together have privatized war. At will, an American living in Yemen can disrupt the life of an American in Washington state. The U.S. government has declared war on a citizen.
Fifth, why the inconsistency, whereby the U.S. government permits itself “targeted killings” but denies this tool to Israel?
Finally, Mr. Awlaki stands at an unprecedented crossroads of death declarations, with his targeting Ms. Norris even as the U.S. government targets him. This is as startling in an Islamic context as it is in an American one. The boundaries of warfare are being stretched in novel, strange and frightening ways.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
TWT Video Picks
By Emily Miller
Obama is losing the debate on gun ownership, concealed-carry permits
Get Breaking Alerts
- USS Kidd sent to Indian Ocean after 'indication' of Malaysian jet crash
- F-35 secrets now showing up in Chinas stealth fighter
- Oil rig worker says he saw missing plane go down: report
- U.S. pilot scares off Iranians with 'Top Gun'-worthy stunt: 'You really ought to go home'
- MILLER: Law enforcement realizes good people with guns deter crime
- GOP bill tries to pull courts into fight with Obama on executive power, enforcing laws
- After three days, Redskins finally address defensive needs
- NRA shirt gets N.Y. high school student suspended
- Snowden: NSA uses fake Facebook to hack into users' computers
- Ben Carson: America's now 'very much like Nazi Germany'
Recent Letters to the Editor
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Wind power less harmful to wildlife
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Constitutional rights are God-given
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Clinton still too inexperienced for presidency
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: The recipe for Asia-Pacific stability
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Obama delivering on 'flexibility' vow to Moscow