- Oscar Pistorius vomits during graphic testimony
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford flubs daylight saving time advice: ‘Turn your clocks back’
- Americans don’t support sending U.S. troops to Ukraine
- Florida lawmakers move to wipe corrupt ‘Boss Hogg’ town from map
- N.C. math whiz to unveil secret of March Madness picks
- An appealing offer: Chiquita merges with Fyffes to make world’s largest banana firm
- Amnesty International says Syria guilty of war crimes for food blockade
- Mitch McConnell on beating tea party: ‘We are going to crush them’
- Adam Lanza’s dad: He would’ve killed me ‘in a heartbeat’
- North Korea holds election: 100% turnout, Kim Jong-un gets — 100% of vote
A ‘pricey’ contract to overhaul Southeast D.C. hospital hit barriers
D.C. officials awarded a $12.7 million contract to overhaul chronically troubled, city-owned United Medical Center to an out-of-town firm that failed to meet minority subcontract requirements, according to local competitors citing city law.
The D.C. Council must approve the recent selection of Chicago-based Huron Healthcare and its local partner, Compass Solutions, by March 4, according to council member Yvette M. Alexander, Ward 7 Democrat and chairwoman of the Committee on Health, who described the contract as “quite pricey for what they are tasked to do.”
Wayne Turnage, director of the Department of Health Care Finance who oversees the Southeast hospital — the only one east of the Anacostia River — said the “turnaround” contract is necessary to get the facility in shape for sale to a private operator. A recent report shows the hospital lost more than $13 million in fiscal 2012.
“There are three options: Do nothing and watch the losses grow, try and sell it as-is — which is unlikely — or fix it and make it sustainable so we have options,” said Mr. Turnage, who deferred questions about the contract award process to James Staton, director of the Office of Contracts and Procurement.
Multiple emails directed to Mr. Turnage, Mr. Staton and numerous council members question whether Huron should have been disqualified at the outset of the selection process because its bid did not include a certified minority subcontractor.
Huron officials did not return calls seeking comment.
In September, four national firms submitted bid proposals for the contract: Huron, Navigant Consulting Inc., FTI Consulting and Quorum Health Resources, according to sources familiar with the process. After a review, Huron and Navigant were chosen as finalists, those sources said, although only Quorum and Navigant, a firm with more than 500 employees in the District, had included subcontractors that city records show as being certified as local minority firms.
Huron’s bid included a local subcontractor, but it was not a certified minority firm, according to city records. The D.C. Code states that contract bids “shall be deemed non responsive” if a prime contractor submits a subcontracting plan that does not include a current, certified minority firm as part of its bid or proposal.
In November, a subcontractor with Navigant emailed D.C. Council members and stated that, according to D.C. law, Huron’s bid should be deemed “non-responsive.” The emails, obtained by The Washington Times, requested that Mr. Turnage and Mr. Staton ensure compliance with D.C. law.
While the bid issue lingered, another irregularity arose: In late December, the city's contracting office decided to redo the “best and final offer” stage, which is supposed to involve interviews with a technical review panel of representatives from the Department of Health Care Finance and United Medical Center, according to those familiar with the process.
According to a D.C. official with knowledge of the matter, the do-over was prompted by an unrelated adverse ruling from the city’s Contract Appeals Board that prompted Mr. Staton to reassess all pending contract awards.
The effect of the second “best and final offer” — usually intended to elicit the lowest-priced offer with the most favorable terms — was to delay the selection process and, according to critics, provide Huron with a competitive advantage unrelated to price. In fact, Huron’s price exceeded the original $10 million budget.
During the delay, Huron dropped subcontractor HGM Management and Technologies, which city records show was not certified as a local minority business, and added Compass Solutions, which is. Eventually, the company was awarded the contract, with an additional $2.7 million added to the price.
A spokeswoman for the city's contracting office said bidders are “permitted to amend a subcontracting plan” until the “final round” of best and final offers. The Office of Contracts and Procurement’s “priority is to get the best possible value for the District’s dollars,” she said.
Mr. Turnage said he was unaware of any problems that would have prompted a second best and final offer, but he did acknowledge receiving emails pointing to alleged flaws in the selection process. Still, he vouched for Compass as a reputable local company and for the process in general.
“I think we got a good firm and whether they got a competitive advantage is not for me to address,” he said. “It’s for reasons like this that I don’t get involved with the procurement process.”
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
TWT Video Picks
Taxpayers must pay the freight for over-budget train projects
- Kim Jong-un calls for execution of 33 Christians
- Rand Paul wins 2014 CPAC straw poll, Ted Cruz finishes a distant second
- Senate Democrats, Republicans spar over restoring unemployment benefits
- CURL: Today's GOP really is Reagan's 'Big Tent' party
- As Crimea falls, Obama takes Key Largo golf vacation, Biden hits Virgin Islands
- Russia besieges Crimea as U.S. seeks diplomacy; Putin remains undeterred by Obama's sanctions
- SAUERBREY: Taxing Marylanders until they flee
- Mitch McConnell on beating tea party: 'We are going to crush them'
- Investigators puzzle: How does a 777 jetliner just disappear into thin air?
- Florida lawmakers move to wipe corrupt 'Boss Hogg' town from map
Pope Francis meets his 'mini-me'
Celebrity deaths in 2014
Winter storm hits states — again