- Obama not worried about Ebola at upcoming African summit in D.C.
- Obama: ‘We tortured some folks’ after 9/11
- Obama administration asked whole D.C. Circuit to take on major Obamacare case
- Mark Levin: Topple GOP leadership or country will ‘unravel’
- Massachusetts to let police chief deny gun buys to those deemed unfit
- John Kerry condemns attack on Israeli soldiers, kidnapping
- U.S. starts to evacuate American Ebola patients from West Africa: Report
- Geraldo slammed as ‘dummy’ for backing Clinton’s bin Laden claim
- Israeli spokesman: No need to debate who broke the cease-fire
- 35 Palestinians killed; Israeli officer missing
Abortion foes condemn Wisconsin capital’s buffer plan
Opponents proceed with lawsuit, as officials modify zones
Question of the Day
City officials in Madison, Wisconsin have “tweaked” a far-reaching new buffer-zone law designed to keep demonstrators far away from health care facilities, but abortion opponents vow to proceed with their lawsuit to block the law.
The battle is one of a number playing out across the country as both sides await a Supreme Court decision on the constitutionality of such exclusion zones.
The Madison law illegally suppresses all kinds of free speech, said Matthew S. Bowman, an attorney with Alliance Defending Freedom who represents Madison Vigil for Life, Students for Life Madison and Badger Catholics in a lawsuit against the ordinance.
Madison city leaders have “created scores, if not hundreds, of anti-leafletting bubbles all over Madison” — not just around Planned Parenthood sites, but on campus and downtown, said Mr. Bowman. “Why? Because they want to suppress their political opponents.”
The law’s main sponsor, Alder Lisa Subeck, asked for the law to be reconsidered so she could make some “minor tweaks” in it, based on recommendations of Madison’s city attorney. Late Tuesday night, the city’s Common Council adopted her new version of the law without discussion or dissent.
Instead of creating 160-foot buffer zones around health care offices, the law now creates 100-foot buffer zones around facilities, plus 30-foot buffer zones around driveways or parking lot entrances. The zones affect any offices used by a licensed physician or nurse practitioner to perform medical treatment, including free-standing offices and those in multioffice buildings, but the legal and constitutional fight has centered squarely on abortion.
“Entrance” is defined as any doorway to those offices — which means that in many buildings, “the sandwich shop has a 100-foot anti-leafletting bubble around it,” said Mr. Bowman.
He and the pro-life clients say the law is unconstitutional because, within the buffer zones, people are forbidden to distribute a leaflet, display a sign, or engage in “oral protest, education or counseling” with someone without consent. Violators can be fined between $50 and $1,000.
Earlier this month, U.S. District Judge William M. Conley in the Western District of Wisconsin denied the plaintiffs’ request for a temporary injunction of the law.
Ms. Subeck said the law is needed to permit people to enter and exit health care facilities without obstruction. NARAL Pro-choice Wisconsin has praised the city council for standing up for “patient privacy and dignity.”
The federal Freedom to Access to Clinic Entrances Act criminalizes efforts to block traffic in and out of clinics, or to deface properties.
But a few states and cities have sought to provide extra protection for abortion-clinic employees and patients by adding no-protest “buffer” zones around facilities and “floating” zones around people walking to or from the clinics. Currently in New Hampshire, state senators have passed a bill to create a 25-foot buffer zone around reproductive health clinics; the bill is before the state’s House of Representatives, where it is expected to pass.
In January, pro-life activists, led by Eleanor McCullen, 77, asked the Supreme Court to overturn a Massachusetts law that creates a clearly marked, 35-foot buffer zone around the doorways of abortion clinics. Ms. McCullen said the law forces her to stop at an arbitrary, government-imposed line in the pavement, even when she is in a consensual conversation with someone. This violates her constitutional rights, Ms. McCullen said.
Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley countered that the 2007 law is legal and ended confrontations around the abortion clinics.
A ruling is expected by June.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Cheryl Wetzstein covers family and social issues as a national reporter for The Washington Times. She has been a reporter for three decades, working in New York City and Washington, D.C. Since joining The Washington Times in 1985, she has been a features writer, environmental and consumer affairs reporter, and assistant business editor.
Beginning in 1994, Mrs. Wetzstein worked exclusively ...
- Massachusetts lawmakers OK new abortion clinic buffer law
- Mississippi abortion law can't be enforced
- Federal appeals court rules against Virginia's gay marriage ban
- Events honoring 20th National Parents' Day reaffirm family
- '50 Shades' movie trailer outrages anti-porn groups
Latest Blog Entries
- Gay therapy ban author seeks Calif. House seat
- Transgender 'bathroom law' gets 5,000 more signatures
- Pro-life, stem-cell bill signed into law by Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback
- N. Dakota lawmakers approve tough abortion bill
- Pope Benedict XVI's successor should allow priests to get a new title: Husband, poll finds
TWT Video Picks
By Orrin G. Hatch
Procedural changes impede the chamber's traditional deliberative function
- Border agents cleared of civil rights complaints from illegal immigrant children
- U.N. condemns Israel, U.S. for not sharing Iron Dome with Hamas
- Obama military strategy too weak for future security, panel reports
- Porn-surfing feds blame boredom, lack of work for misbehavior
- Ben Carson takes major step toward presidential campaign
- Feds raid S.C. home to seize Land Rover in EPA emission-control crackdown
- Ted Nugent slams 'lying freaks' at liberal media: I'm 'doing God's work'
- CRUZ: A tale of two hospitals: One in Israel, one in Gaza
- Report: 40% of weapons sent to Afghanistan are unaccounted for
- House backs faster deportations, cancels 'Dreamer' policy
Top 10 U.S. military helicopters
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors