- The Washington Times - Thursday, December 16, 2004

Justice never sleeps. Or rather the free-floating moralism that is the left never sleeps. The other day a Chilean judge, Juan Guzman Tapia, decided an 89-year-old man was competent to stand trial for human-rights abuses, though it has been 14 years since he left office, and when he did he handed his hitherto troubled country over to democrats and eventual prosperity. The 89-year-old man is, of course, Gen. Augusto Pinochet, and his human-rights abuses are not even reported in the newspapers as “alleged” human-rights abuses.

For the New York Times on Tuesday, Judge Guzman’s decision was Page One news — in fact, the day’s major news story with a color picture of Judge Guzman embraced by Gen. Pinochet’s emotional opponents. The photograph dominated three columns.

In the body of the Times’ article, the word “communist” never appeared, only “Marxists.” For all the untutored reader might know, Gen. Pinochet’s victims might have been the country’s librarians or butterfly collectors.

That word, “Marxists,” appeared in a quote from Gen. Pinochet who said a year ago on a Spanish-language television show: “Everything I did I would do again. Who am I supposed to ask for forgiveness? They are the ones who have to ask me for forgiveness, them, the Marxists.” The old boy came to power in 1973. For six months before he took over, politicians and private citizens in large numbers had been imploring the military to deliver Chile from President Salvador Allende, a romantic and incompetent Marxist pseudo-intellectual who spent his last year in a drunken haze while economic chaos spread.

For the next 17 years Gen. Pinochet, his military and his secret police waged war against leftists, usually within Chile but occasionally abroad through a series of political assassinations. Gen. Pinochet’s political assassinations were not as numerous as those practiced by Soviet satellite countries. Nor was his war as bloody as Generallisimo Francisco Franco’s war against communists and other leftists in the 1930s, but it was brutal enough to offend civil libertarians everywhere, including me.

Yet, like Franco, he did return his country to democracy. How many communists have done that? Moreover communism accounted for scores of millions of innocent victims in the 20th century. Gen. Pinochet’s regime allegedly accounted for 4,000, not all of them peace-loving progressives. How many has Fidel Castro murdered, tortured, and jailed? Today Mr. Castro remains a bloody tyrant and far more of a problem beyond his shores than the general with the absurd sunglasses and 18th-century uniforms ever was.

Finally, when Fidel ultimately croaks, he will have left what was once the most prosperous country in Latin America in a heap. Do any of Gen. Pinochet’s current tormentors demand Mr. Castro’s prosecution for crimes against humanity?

There are two points worth noting here. One is that the left — whether communist or simply glassy-eyed reformist — never tires in hunting down its enemies. The other is that its enemies are always on the right — or at least the perceived right. The old Soviet Bloc countries are filled with retired brutes who did far more damage to the civil liberties and the prosperity of their countries than Gen. Pinochet ever did. There is no effort to prosecute these enemies of freedom commensurate with the effort against Gen. Pinochet.

If indeed the prosecution of Gen. Pinochet would elevate regard for human rights worldwide, I would be among the first to celebrate Judge Guzman’s decision. Yet it is not the opponents of Gen. Pinochet who have made great strides in elevating human rights worldwide. Rather it has been North Americans and Europeans, most notably the English-speaking peoples. Right now those people are leading the world in a struggle against tyrants who, unlike an 89-year-old retired general, can actually shoot back. How prominent have Gen. Pinochet’s opponents been in the struggle against Islamofascism and the sadistic Saddam Hussein? The answer is not very. In fact, many of those cheering for Gen. Pinochet’s neck today blithely lump Prime Minister Tony Blair and President George W. Bush into the same category they reserve for Gen. Pinochet.

There is a great deal of posturing about civil liberties and justice in the campaign against Gen. Pinochet. There is also something else. It is difficult to explain but it is observable. The left worldwide reserves its hostility for people on the right and for America and its allies, who are the real guarantors of the rights of man.

R. Emmett Tyrrell Jr. is the founder and editor in chief of the American Spectator, a contributing editor to the New York Sun, and an adjunct scholar at the Hudson Institute. His most recent book is “Madame Hillary: The Dark Road to the White House.”

LOAD COMMENTS ()

 

Click to Read More

Click to Hide