Monday, November 16, 2026

As concerns mount over addictive algorithms, online predators, and youth mental health, a fierce debate is unfolding over how far the government should go to protect children online. Should Washington impose age restrictions and social media bans, or do those policies threaten adult privacy and free speech? And should states ban smartphones in public schools?

Josh Golin, Executive Director at Fair Play, and Jennifer Huddleston, Senior Fellow in Technology Policy at the Cato Institute, join Billy Hallowell on “The Dialogue” to debate these urgent questions, clashing over safety-by-design regulations, school phone bans, and whether parents or policymakers should draw the line.

People were interested in these podcasts

The claims discussed are those made in the debate and do not represent the views of The Washington Times.

[HALLOWELL] Welcome to “The Dialogue” from The Washington Times. In this episode, we’re tackling an important question: How far should the government go to protect kids online? 

With growing concerns over social media, online predators, and addictive algorithms, there is plenty of debate over what should happen, who should be responsible for keeping kids safe? Is it parents, tech companies, the government, or a mixture of all of those? Our two panelists today have some great thoughts and perspectives on these issues. 

Today, I’m joined by Josh Golin, Executive Director at Fairplay, and Jennifer Huddleston, Senior Fellow in Technology Policy at the Cato Institute.

We start the show with something we call The Pitch. And the pitch is basically we throw out our general statement and you each get about 30 seconds to respond to it. 

The statement is: Government should impose stricter regulations on social media to protect children.

[HUDDLESTON] When we talk about protecting children online, we’re talking about a lot of different topics. That’s because every child and every parent and every household is unique. These are very individual problems, which means that policy is going to be a sledgehammer for what individual families need to decide for themselves.

But beyond what this means for children, we also have to think about what this means for all internet users. Because a lot of times when we look at policies aimed at protecting young people, they could have significant impacts on things like anonymous speech and the data privacy of adults as well.

[HALLOWELL] That was our 30 seconds. Now, Josh, what would you say about that?

[GOLIN] We absolutely need more government regulations to protect children online. Congress has not passed a law to protect kids online since 1998, which is before we even had smartphones or social media. We know from internal documents from companies like Meta that they have a deliberate strategy, which is to addict kids by any means necessary. And that is harming kids both by the amount of time that they are spending online, which displaces activities that are good for them, and by exposing them to all sorts of other harms because these platforms choose maximizing engagement over safety every single time.

[HALLOWELL] That gives us a little taste of what we’re going to be getting into today. Now that moves us into our Focus section. What we do on The Focus is present three claims generally. I’m going to read the first claim to you.

It’s another statement: Government-imposed age restrictions and social media bans are effective ways to protect children online.

[GOLIN] I think that there are better ways of protecting children online. I am concerned about social media bans for a few reasons.

Number one, I do not think that social media is inherently harmful to kids. I think social media, the way it is currently designed and the way that the current business practices of the social media companies of designing for addiction and trying to maximize engagement at all costs, I think that is harmful. But I think theoretically, social media could provide opportunities for teens to learn and connect with others. That wouldn’t be harmful. I don’t necessarily want to throw out the baby with the bathwater. 

I am also concerned that when we do these social media bans, teens will find a way around them. Teens are very technologically savvy and they, if you if you say they can’t go on something, they will probably find a way to go on social media anyway. And if we don’t change the behavior of the platforms through policy, they will be going on platforms and they will be completely unprotected. And so even the protections that companies have put in, which I don’t think necessarily work very well, but every kid will be treated as an adult if they are sneaking on and pretending that they are 19 in order to access social media. So I think a much better approach is safety by design, where these companies are required to put in certain safety features and limit the data that they’re collecting on kids and limiting the ways that they are able to monetize children’s data, I think that is a much preferable way of protecting them than bans. And that is what Fair Play advocates for.

Having said that, I work every day with parents who are enormously frustrated by companies like Meta and TikTok, not just because they refuse to make their platform safer for kids, not just because they have this business strategy of trying to addict kids at any cost, but also because they lobby vociferously against any legislation that would require them to make their platform safer. So I understand the frustration of those parents. And honestly, I think if companies like Meta continue to block common-sense legislation like the Kids Online Safety Act, then we should look to bans because if we can’t make the platform safer, then we need to look to other policies like bans. But as I said, my first preference would be to create safety regulations and privacy regulations that these companies need to adhere to when they know that a user is a child.

[HALLOWELL] Okay, so Jennifer, we’re going to talk about some of the other things that Josh just raised in a moment, but I want to come back to this. The government posed age restrictions and then the social media bans. They’re two different things, but they sort of coexist and interact. Are those effective ways to protect children?

[HUDDLESTON] We have more and more evidence looking at places around the world that shows they’re ineffective. And in fact, in some cases, they may actually undermine their stated goals. They may actually make children less safe online. If we look somewhere like Australia, what we saw is that the majority of young people who were online on social media platforms before the ban ran into effect are still on those platforms now. However, beyond that, we also see that a lot of young people have gone to platforms that have less protections available, things that parents might not be as familiar with or know how to help them navigate. As a result, we saw kind of different platforms becoming popular because they weren’t included under this social media ban. And we’ve seen that young people flock to those that might have less safety elements available for parents to navigate.

Beyond that, we’ve also seen some interesting evidence that young people, for example, are less informed on current events in Australia after the ban went into effect. And there’s a lot of ongoing questions around what these also mean for the expression rights of young people, how these platforms give them an important space to have conversations with each other. I think it’s also important to think about how far these definitions of social media can go and what happens when young people find a different solution. Do we see the government trying to crack down even more harshly, as we’ve seen in some cases, expanding that definition? Or how are we going to help young people have the tools to safely navigate social media and communication with each other? 

Watch the video for the full conversation.

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.