- Thursday, November 19, 2026

Regardless of the underlying reason, the Democrats won a sweeping victory in the midterms. They flipped enough Senate seats to enter the 120th Congress with 56 members and control of both chambers.

Rather than bask in the victory, party activists interpret the scale of the win as a demand for change. In furtherance of that call, Rep. Chris Van Hollen, Maryland Democrat, is challenging longtime leader Charles E. Schumer for majority leader in a Dec. 1 secret-ballot vote.

Mr. Schumer insists that he has the votes, but Mr. Van Hollen claims the race is “very much in flux.” Calling himself the “underdog,” Mr. Van Hollen has already been backed by Sen. Bernard Sanders, a Vermont independent who caucuses with the Democrats, and Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan. Most of the other incoming senators are making noises suggesting Mr. Schumer will not have their support.

People were interested in these podcasts

Such a contest among Democrats is unusual, as it is not about style, age or willingness to take on President Trump. Rather, it is the first clear public expression of the Democratic Party’s accelerating turn against Israel — and Jews.

Mr. Schumer is the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in American history. He has long called himself a shomer Yisrael, a guardian of Israel. He reliably supports the U.S.-Israel alliance, has opposed efforts to condition or cut military aid and has been a prominent critic of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s leadership.

In March 2024, he went further than most other senior Democrats, calling for new elections in Israel because Mr. Netanyahu had “lost his way.” That is insufficient for the party’s new voices, who note that Mr. Schumer remains one of the few Senate Democrats who consistently vote against resolutions to block arms transfers to Israel.

In a caucus that has moved sharply leftward on Israel, those votes mark Mr. Schumer as untrustworthy amid a push to recalibrate the U.S.-Israel relationship.

Mr. Van Hollen, on the other hand, fits in nicely with the Senate newcomers. He votes to restrict the sale of offensive weapons to Israel and co-authored a report with Sen. Jeff Merkley, Oregon Democrat, declaring that the Netanyahu government was implementing “ethnic cleansing” of Palestinians.

He has called Mr. Netanyahu a “wanted war criminal” and “chronic liar,” citing the International Criminal Court’s arrest warrants, and has criticized the American Israel Public Affairs Committee’s role in Democratic primaries.

Days before announcing his leadership bid, Mr. Van Hollen spearheaded an effort to remove deeper U.S.-Israel defense technology and intelligence-sharing provisions from the FY2027 National Defense Authorization Act. Progressive groups and some incoming senators believe these should be the party’s new positions.

The February 2026 Gallup survey showed that 65% of Democrats say their sympathies lie more with the Palestinians than Israel. Only 17% said they backed the Israelis. In 2014, by contrast, Democratic sympathy for Israel peaked at 58%.

The post-Oct. 7, 2023, surge in progressive activism, campus encampments, Democratic Socialists of America influence and primary challenges turned “critic of Israel” into a resume asset in the party. Members elected on Nov. 3 include several who ran explicitly against the U.S.-Israel relationship or AIPAC.

Mr. Schumer’s continued support for Israel’s security, even if hedged, has become a liability inside his own caucus.

Democrats spent the cycle arguing that they were the adults who would check Mr. Trump and deliver for working people. Yet once the ballots were counted and the majority secured, the first order of business for many was not to unify around legislative priorities or to staff the committees. It was replacing the Jewish leader whose record on Israel is too pro-ally for the new median of the party.

Mr. Van Hollen calls it answering “the call of the American people.” Yet the people who elected the incoming majority did not, by and large, vote on the Gaza Strip. The activists and primary voters who shaped Democratic internal politics did.

Mr. Schumer’s real offense is that he has not fully adapted to a party in which open hostility to Israel’s government has expanded into hostility toward the idea of a special U.S.-Israel relationship itself.

If Mr. Van Hollen wins, it will be decided: The price of leadership in the Democratic Senate is willingness to treat Israel as a pariah. Even if Mr. Schumer survives, the serious challenge from the left’s preferred Israel critic will have already extracted concessions and further marginalized remaining pro-Israel voices.

That will have long-term electoral consequences.

Both outcomes accelerate one trajectory: Jewish Democrats who still support the U.S.-Israel alliance and once saw the party as their natural home are watching their highest-ranking member treated as the first postelection obstacle to be removed.

That is not generational renewal; it is a factional purge.

• Peter Roff has written about U.S. politics and public policy for a quarter of a century. He appears regularly on U.S. and international media platforms, can be followed on social media @TheRoffDraft and can be reached via RoffColumns@gmail.com.

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.