OPINION:
The Baseball Hall of Fame released its 2027 ballot this week, with 14 new names added to the 13 holdovers up for consideration. Among those newcomers are a handful of players who had a cup of coffee with the Washington Nationals – one of whom came back for refills – and one who embodies the history of the franchise in the District.
It may be their only connection to Cooperstown. As The Athletic’s Tyler Kepner pointed out in his article on the new candidates, only one from last year’s first-time class – pitcher Cole Hamels – received enough votes to be back on this year’s ballot. To return for another shot, a candidate has to get at least 5% of the vote.
There is my dilemma on this year’s ballot – the 5% mark.
People were interested in these podcasts
Here are some of the candidates who wore the Curly W cap, some briefly:
• Starlin Castro: Castro was a four-time All-Star infielder who led the National League in hits in 2011 with the Chicago Cubs, the youngest player in the NL to do so at the age of 21. He was traded to the New York Yankees in 2015 and the Miami Marlins in 2017.
In 2020, the year following Washington’s World Series championship, the Nationals signed Castro to a two-year, $12 million deal to play second base. He broke his wrist that August and was out for the season.
The following year Castro had a strong first half, with a 14-game hitting streak and a .283 average. But that was it. He was placed on administrative leave under Major League Baseball’s domestic violence policy, suspended 30 games and released by Washington at the age of 31. Castro went on to play in the Atlantic League, Mexico and the Dominican Republic.
He had respectable career numbers – 138 home runs, 678 RBI and a .280 average over 11 seasons – but say goodbye to Castro on the Hall of Fame ballot after this one time.
• Jon Lester: The lefthander made his bones with the Boston Red Sox, where over nine years he won 110 games and lost 63, and then with the Chicago Cubs, where Lester posted a 77-44 mark over six seasons and was an important part of the Cubs’ 2016 World Series title.
In his rookie year in 2005 with Boston, Lester was diagnosed with anaplastic large cell lymphoma. He would come back to have what is arguably a Hall of Fame career – a 200-117 won-loss record with a 3.66 ERA and 2,488 strikeouts over 16 seasons.
Lester was an outstanding postseason pitcher – 9-7 overall with a 2.51 ERA. In six World Series games he was 4-1 with a 1.77 ERA.
His claim to fame in Washington? He brought Lane Thomas here.
Lester was signed by the Nationals to a one-year, $5 million contract for the 2021 season. He was ineffective, with a 3-5 record and a 5.02 ERA in 16 starts, but he was traded to the St. Louis Cardinals at the trading deadline for Thomas, who struggled in the minor leagues with staying healthy and being on the field.
It was in Washington where Thomas established himself as a major leaguer, where over four seasons, he batted .257 with 60 home runs and 205 RBI in 424 games and was a strong outfield presence. Thomas was dealt by Washington to the Cleveland Guardians at the 2024 deadline for Jose Tena, Alex Clemmey and Rafael Ramirez Jr. Clemmey, a left-handed pitcher, is still with the Nationals organization. Tena, an infielder-designated hitter, had several stints with the Nationals but was released this month.
• Asdrubal Cabrera: Now we’re talking. Cabrera had two stays in Washington, briefly in 2014 and returning in 2019 to be a key contributor to the Nationals’ World Series title. After being released by the Texas Rangers in August 2019, Cabrera signed with Washington. In 38 games in the infield, playing first, second and third base, Cabrera batted .323 with six home runs and 40 RBI. He went 6 for 21 in the World Series against Houston in seven games.
He finished his 15-year career with 195 home runs, 869 RBI and a .266 average. Nationals fans have fond memories of him, but he will disappear from the Hall of Fame ballot after 2027.
• Ryan Zimmerman: This is the one for Washington fans to celebrate. It’s also the one that may hurt the most.
Zimmerman was the soul of this franchise. Other players may have been better, but they took the Nationals uniform off. Zimmerman never did – 16 seasons, his entire career, in Washington. He was there in the bad years starting in 2005 and there for the glory at the end when he led off the World Series against Houston with a home run off Astros ace Gerrit Cole.
He had a very good career – 284 home runs, 1,061 RBI and a .277 average. Zimmerman was a two-time Silver Slugger Award winner and a Gold Glove, all at third base. He was named to two All-Star teams.
It’s not a Hall of Fame career.
It might have been, if Zimmerman had stayed healthy. He missed large chunks of the 2011, 2013, 2014, 2018 and 2019 seasons with a variety of injuries – abdominal strain, hamstring, fractured thumb, oblique injury. I believe if he had stayed healthy, Zimmerman would be in the Hall of Fame discussion. Not now, though.
Part of Washington’s passion for Zimmerman was the way he carried himself – low-key, never embarrassing the team. He was the first homegrown player Nationals fans could point to with pride. Because of all that, Zimmerman’s number 11 is retired, and he is a member of the Nationals’ Ring of Honor.
But outside of Washington, his low profile won’t help him on the 2027 ballot. He certainly won’t receive 75% of the vote to enter Cooperstown. Zimmerman may not get the 5% needed to stay on the ballot.
He deserves better.
I am a Hall of Fame voter and have been for 23 years. Some voters have voted for players just so they would have the honor of staying on the ballot, knowing they had no chance for election. Others have simply voted for a player so they would have at least one vote recorded to mark their career.
I have never done this. I may now.
• You can hear Thom Loverro on “The Kevin Sheehan Show” podcast.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.