Tuesday, July 20, 2004

Those who flung accusations of “liar” at President Bush and British Prime Minister Tony Blair last summer over the causes of the war with Iraq surely owe the two men an apology. It is, of course, pretty hard to imagine the word “sorry” would ever cross their lips, but if we live in a world where right and wrong mean something, the accusers should eat their words.

Tomorrow, the long-awaited report of the September 11 commission will see the light of day. It follows on the heels of the Senate intelligence report and the so-called Butler report published in London, both of which were mandated to look into intelligence failures before September 11 and in the run-up to the war in Iraq.

The picture that has emerged so far and which will likely be reinforced by the September 11 commission is that, overall, incompetence and lack of good information, not government duplicity, were the problems. Even chief weapons inspector David Kay has remarked that he, too, would have gone to war on the available evidence at the time. However, in one instance at least the information seems to correct: Both reports conclude that Saddam Hussein was indeed seeking to buy enriched uranium in Niger. That’s serious business.

People were interested in these podcasts

One year ago, however, the media and the critics of the war in Iraq (sometimes one and the same) leapt to the conclusion that Mr. Bush and Mr. Blair — being hell-bent on attacking Iraq for their own irrational reasons — were making up all the evidence.

Here’s what Sen. John Kerry, now Democratic candidate for the presidency, had to say about the case made by Mr. Bush in his State of the Union speech: “The Bush administration doesn’t get honesty points for belatedly admitting what has been apparent to the world for some time — that emphatic statements made on Iraq were inaccurate.”

“It’s bad enough that such a glaring blunder became part of the president’s case for war. It’s far worse if the case for war was made by deliberate deception,” stated Sen. Ted Kennedy. “It’s more important than ever that Congress conduct a real investigation into the use of intelligence sources as a justification for war. The American people deserve to know whether the president is making war-and-peace decisions based on reliable information. We cannot risk American lives because of shoddy intelligence or outright lies.”

A lot of these accusations, which proceeded to take on a life of their own, were based on allegations made by one Joseph Wilson, a former diplomat with an ax to grind against the Republican administration and a book to sell ironically titled “The Politics of Truth.”

Mr. Wilson made no secret of his opposition to the war and his profound disdain for the Bush foreign-policy team, which he actively sought to discredit. In a very unfortunate twist, he himself had been proposed by his wife — a CIA analyst by the name of Valerie Plame — for a State Department-sponsored visit to Niger to look into the business with the enriched uranium.

Later, Mr. Wilson claimed that he had found no evidence of Iraqi activity in Niger, but from the two reports, we now know that in fact he did. When it came to the writing of his book and the following publicity tour, Mr. Wilson changed his story. He also launched an aggressive campaign against columnist Robert Novak, who had revealed the name of his wife in a column about the whole affair.

Mr. Wilson explosively alleged in an op-ed article in the New York Times on July 6 last year that the Bush administration had fabricated the stories about the Iraqi nuclear program. “Based on my experience with the administration in the months leading up to the war, I have little choice but to conclude that some of the intelligence related to Iraq’s nuclear weapons program was twisted to exaggerate the Iraqi threat,” he wrote.

Meanwhile, in Britain, a deeply flawed BBC “expose” of the British government’s case for going to war led to the suicide of a scientific adviser to the government, causing a huge popular uproar. A later inquiry vindicated the British government and castigated the BBC, but the war remains deeply unpopular among many Brits.

Today, people like propagandist Michael Moore continue to perpetuate the idea that the case for the Iraq invasion was invented whole cloth in the Bush White House. The elite media are hell-bent on showing Iraq to be a failure, focusing only on the negative and not the efforts to rebuild the country with an Iraqi democratic government in charge.

It is deeply regrettable that, in an election year, the issue of Saddam’s weapons of mass destruction and what happened to them has become dominated by partisan politics, when we should be talking about national security.

Helle Dale is director of Foreign Policy and Defense Studies at the Heritage Foundation. E-mail: helle.dale@heritage.org.

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.