- The Washington Times - Tuesday, October 13, 2009

One of the best aspects of the 2009 novel H1N1 flu virus is that most people infected get nothing worse than the symptoms of a bad cold.

But the worst and most mysterious aspect is that the disease strikes an unusually large number of healthy young people and can be fatal for adolescents and young adults even when they receive intensive care treatment, according to two studies released Monday.

“Young healthy people who have had no underlying condition: that is humbling and mysterious. It is rare, but once you see it, you never forget it. You pour in the antibacterials and pray,” Dr. John Bartlett, a professor of medicine and a former director of infectious diseases at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, told The Washington Times.

The two surveys, released by the Journal of the American Medical Association for the Nov. 4 issue, covered intensive care unit (ICU) patients in Mexico and Canada during the early phases of the global H1N1 pandemic.

Both showed that the largest numbers of H1N1 deaths occurred in the adults and early middle-age ranges - 21 of 24 deaths in the Mexican study occurred in the 20-to-50 age group, as did 14 of the 29 Canadian deaths.

The Mexican study also showed that the largest number of ICU admissions occurred in that age group.

This is not the usual pattern for flu, which hits the youngest and the oldest, Dr. Bartlett said about the studies, with which he was not involved.

The surveys also showed a considerable gap in the deadliness of the virus commonly referred to as swine flu. Mexican hospitals had more than twice the fatality rate among flu cases that already had become bad enough to reach the ICU, where most received medical ventilation and the best possible medical care.

The 24 deaths in Mexico occurred within two months of ICU admission among 58 patients in six hospitals, a mortality rate of 41 percent. Just 17 percent of 168 Canadian ICU cases - 29 people - had died within that survey’s 90-day follow-up period.

The average patient age in the Canada study was 32.3 years; in Mexico, 44 years. Twenty-one, or 36 percent, of Mexican patients were obese; no similar figure was given for Canada. In all cases, conditions worsened upon admission to the hospital, “often in young adults,” the Canadian study noted.

The lead author of the Canadian study, Dr. Anand Kumar, commented how unusual it was to have the patients become so ill so suddenly and warned of a real risk that local health care systems in the U.S. and anywhere else “would be overwhelmed.”

“These people were not just a little bit ill. They were spectacularly ill,” Dr. Kumar told Health Day News. “To see 40 patients like this simultaneously in the ICU, all struggling for their lives, all in the space of a few weeks - that’s really unusual.”

However, epidemiologists such as Dr. Bartlett cautioned against hysteria based on the two studies, calling it “a numbers game” that depends on how widespread the H1N1 virus becomes and noting also that “infectious care centers are breeding grounds for diseases.”

“Nobody knows all the people who got sick with it,” he said. “Keep in perspective the number of people who have died from flu is small compared to the numbers infected.”

The disparity in the Canadian and Mexican figures, he suggested, “probably means is a better level of care, especially for very complicated care given in an intensive-care unit in a modern facility. We can [keep people alive on respirators] for a long time.”

But he was reluctant to blame the Mexican health care system, the country’s poverty or other social factors. He called Mexico’s response to the new flu strain “terrific. It was a country trying the best it can.”

“Don’t forget they didn’t even have a diagnostic test in May when the thing exploded in Mexico, and then on May 10 a 10-year-old boy in San Diego, who had access to a big diagnostic machine. This was a different virus than we ever had seen.”

It was also very “humbling” for the medical establishment, he said: “A lot of very smart people have spent a lifetime studying influenza, and nobody saw this coming. This was an odd assortment - avian, pig and people’s genes all brewing in a pig for eight years and all of a sudden it is exploding.”

Dr. Bartlett also expressed worry about the pressure put on intensive care units, referring to an Australian study that reported “a 14-fold increase in the population in ICUs during their swine flu season” in the Southern Hemisphere.

Johns Hopkins already is feeling the burden of patients with severe H1N1 symptoms, said Dr. Trish Perl, another department of medicine professor and specialist in infectious diseases.

Of particular concern is America’s ICUs outrunning their supply of ventilators - essential to treatment of the worst flu cases, Dr. Bartlett said.

“You have heard about the huge government supply of vaccine and Tamiflu, but you haven’t heard about a big government supply of ventilators,” he said. Intensive care units “are already at a breaking point and have been that way for the past 10 years. Half of emergency rooms operate at full capacity.”

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide