OPINION:
Eight years ago, I was sitting at my desk, preparing to file a lawsuit to save the lives of two very little girls, Emma and Isabella. They were only 5 days old. They were embryos.
It was a case of first impression, the likes of which no court had ever ruled on in the United States. The system had failed. Reasonable communication had failed. Mediation had failed. The only hope my clients had left was a Hail Mary that a Louisiana judge might see the circumstances of their case and offer to rule in their favor. The stakes were high.
Now, eight years later, the girls’ lives are still on cryogenic hold. The judge dismissed the case between actor and director Nick Loeb and his former fiancee, “Modern Family” star Sofia Vergara — two Hollywood figures who had frozen their embryos. Needless to say, the case made headlines.
People were interested in these podcasts
The lawsuit was an uphill climb and made me one of the first lawyers to have litigated an embryo custody lawsuit. There are, however, plenty of lawsuits to go around.
Between 400,000 and 1 million-plus embryos created through in vitro fertilization, or IVF, are in suspended existence in the U.S. alone. Industry tracking and reporting are inadequate, and estimates vary widely.
Each of these embryos is, in the best case, awaiting transfer, implantation and birth. More likely, though, they face yearslong frozen stasis until eventual death via a breakup, equipment failure, or vandalism.
In this past week, IVF has gone from one among many reproductive options that Americans were generally aware of but not necessarily educated on to a topic of dinner table and water cooler conversation. With an extraordinary amount of misinformation going around about this case, many people are claiming more knowledge than they should.
That’s because on Feb. 16, the Alabama Supreme Court, in LePage v. Mobile Infirmary Clinic, ruled that frozen embryos should be considered children and that people can be held legally responsible for destroying them under the state’s “wrongful death of a minor” law.
For background, three sets of Alabama parents sued the clinic, their IVF provider, after the clinic, which had offered to freeze the couples’ yet-to-be-implanted embryos, failed to keep their tiny offspring safe.
In December 2020, a client at the Mobile hospital where the frozen embryos were stored walked through an “unsecured doorway” and tampered with several embryos from the cryogenic nursery. That client’s hand was “freeze-burned” by the extremely low temperatures the embryos were stored in, causing the client to drop them on the floor, killing them.
The parents sued for wrongful death.
After being denied by the trial court, the state Supreme Court vindicated them, ruling that “extrauterine children” — unborn children “located outside of a biological uterus at the time they are killed” — are indeed children.
That embryos are children should surprise no one, least of all the IVF clinics whose business is parenthood. It is a simple fact endorsed by embryology textbooks and backed by the logic that something doesn’t change from a human being to an object based on where you put it.
In reality, despite popular news reports, the court’s decision does not ban IVF, nor should it result in fewer babies being born in Alabama. Rather, the decision protects hopeful parents who can now hold the largely unregulated, often fly-by-night IVF industry responsible for negligence and a lack of safeguards to protect their children.
Unlike hospitals and day care centers, in which parents also entrust the care of their children, IVF and other fertility clinics need stricter regulations requiring advanced security, redundant backup systems, and safeguards that prevent the lingering legacy of doctors who have used their own sperm to fertilize clients’ eggs.
Clinics claim this would increase their liability costs — an expense they will undoubtedly pass along to their fertility clients. They need to, however, have a much greater concern about wrongfully destroying embryos they claim they will protect. Remember, most custody disputes (and equipment failures) don’t end in the death of a child.
As one of the parents’ attorneys put it, “What we can’t have is a situation where these clinics are not subject to civil justice.” Fertility clinics need to be held accountable, and it’s up to lawmakers to tackle any policy issues that arise from the Alabama ruling.
Fueled by fearmongering, the world has big feelings about the Alabama Supreme Court ruling. Even former President Donald Trump has weighed in, vowing to protect IVF — which, again, is not at stake. He was right when he said we should “support the creation of strong, thriving, healthy American families” and “make it easier for mothers and fathers to have babies, not harder.”
So let’s do just that — in this case, by regulating the IVF industry, and making sure that when they say they will keep our children safe, they keep their promise.
• Catherine Glenn Foster is a constitutional attorney and president and CEO of First Rights Global, a position she assumed after a six-year tenure leading Americans United for Life, the country’s original pro-life organization, and a storied legal career on the issues of life, liberty and human rights.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.