- Wednesday, November 18, 2026

“Your llamas were used as props in the video, and that’s illegal.”

That is not a line from a Wes Anderson movie. It is exactly what a U.S. Forest Service law enforcement officer said to Josh Smunk, the owner of a llama guiding business for hunters in Wyoming.

The statement was not in reference to llama welfare or llamas as contraband. It was made because the Forest Service has long held that it is a violation of federal statute to “monetize” any photography or videography conducted in a federally designated wilderness area.

People were interested in these podcasts

The llamas were allegedly helping Mr. Smunk commit a crime.

Mr. Smunk participated in a perfectly legal hunt with friends in the Shoshone National Forest. Parts of the forest are designated as “wilderness,” a term of art in federal law. While they were in the wilderness, the hunters filmed themselves sitting around a campfire discussing the day’s hunt. Two of Mr. Smunk’s llamas, which he rents out to hunters as pack animals, were standing in the background.

Yet because the video was later “monetized” on YouTube by the content creator — at a likely rate of less than a quarter-cent per view — the llamas became “props,” and therefore allegedly constituted a violation of the Wilderness Act of 1964.

Violations of the Wilderness Act can result in a ban on the use of public lands, imprisonment of up to six months and fines of up to $5,000.

Mr. Smunk got off with a warning. Still, confused by the seeming absurdity of what he had just been told, he started investigating the threat. He asked local Forest Service representatives to explain the law to him. Did the recently enacted EXPLORE Act not allow for commercial filming on federal lands? No.

“The Wilderness Act takes precedence over the EXPLORE Act.” Could he film strictly for personal use? Yes. “You can film BUT [it] has to be for your personal use — just like we explained that day here at the office.”

What if Mr. Smunk received a quarter-cent per view on YouTube? “You can not monetize it thru ’clicks,’ etc.” Does this mean the Forest Service is actively monitoring social media channels to identify people who have monetized content filmed in wilderness areas? Yes. “As people post these types of ’commercial’ filming products, and we find them, we do go after them.”

The bottom line: “As soon [as] money is involved it becomes a commercial enterprise and you have to have a permit.”

It should be noted that these permits are rarely issued — think one every couple of years — and are never issued for hunting films. The idea that Mr. Smunk could ever get a permit is laughable. What he was really being told is that no one may ever monetize any content filmed in a wilderness area.

This prohibition is unconstitutional under the First Amendment of the Constitution. The Supreme Court was unequivocal in holding that the government may enact content-based restrictions on speech only if it satisfies strict scrutiny — the most stringent level of constitutional review. This requires a “compelling interest” and “narrow tailoring,” neither of which is present here.

Ask the Forest Service why it has this long-standing rule, and it will tell you that it is necessary to prevent overcrowding in wilderness areas. If too many people know about a beautiful place, it may lead to too many of them visiting.

Yet reducing the number of people interested in legally visiting public lands is not a governmental interest at all, much less a compelling one. Even if it were, this law is not narrowly tailored to accomplish that goal.

Instead, the real lesson, which governments have been slow to learn, is that monetized speech is entitled to the same constitutional protection as nonmonetized speech.

News outlet websites expect to make money from their content, whether through advertising or subscriptions. If such “commercialization” were enough to strip news articles of First Amendment protections, then neither journalism nor the performing arts would have protection under the strict scrutiny standard because almost every journalist, ballerina and actor works for money.

This would open the floodgates for governmental interference with and regulation of all sorts of speech.

That is why Mr. Smunk, together with the nonprofit BlueRibbon Coalition, has sued the Forest Service in federal court. If you have the right to take photos or video in a wilderness area, then you also have the right to sell what you have created.

This rule is not about limiting the number of people on a film crew or the amount of equipment used. It attempts to prohibit and punish speech simply because someone made a few bucks off it. Fortunately, the First Amendment does not work that way.

Some people believe that wilderness is something the government can control without limits — even to the point of requiring you to get a permit to take a picture of a mountain or tree.

Humans are seen as a clear and present danger to “wilderness,” so wilderness must be closed, restricted, permitted and monitored. This impulse denies Americans an important part of their national heritage and birthright.

The ability to strike out on public lands, alone or with friends and family, allows us to breathe a little easier when we are back home in the city.

Mr. Smunk is fighting for everyone’s ability to enjoy the wilderness in ordinary ways and share that experience with others through photos and video — even if a prop llama is in the background.

• Matt Miller is a senior fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation’s Center for the American Future.

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.