OPINION:
Russian historian and former Soviet political prisoner Alexander Skobov is once again behind bars. Arrested for opposing Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, he has been sentenced to 16 years in prison.
When the Trump administration proposed relaxing sanctions against Russia in exchange for the release of some political prisoners, Mr. Skobov categorically refused to be part of the bargain. Easing sanctions, he argued, would help Russia continue its aggression.
From prison, he was prepared to sacrifice his own freedom rather than contribute to the killing of Ukrainians.
People were interested in these podcasts
President Trump seems unlikely to appreciate Mr. Skobov’s heroism.
Days later, Mr. Trump announced an agreement to relax restrictions on Russian diesel exports — not to save lives, but in the hope of lowering American fuel prices. He subsequently waived the application of additional sanctions authorized by Congress.
Meanwhile, Ukraine faced restrictions on American-supported satellite communications, interruptions in early-warning intelligence, delays in air defense missiles and pressure to stop striking Russian refineries.
These steps weakened Ukraine’s defenses as Russia intensified its attacks on Ukrainian cities, killing more civilians and damaging infrastructure essential to surviving the coming winter. Concessions from Washington have not persuaded Russian President Vladimir Putin to end his aggression. Instead, they risk convincing him that further violence will bring still more concessions.
Mr. Trump’s decisions raise two questions: Will they meaningfully benefit Americans? Even if they do, are the benefits worth the moral and strategic costs?
The economic case is doubtful. Recent diesel price increases have been driven primarily by disruptions caused by the war in Iran, not by the war in Ukraine.
The Russian diesel shipments initially promised under Mr. Trump’s agreement are small relative to the global market. Russia itself has experienced fuel shortages, raising questions about how much it can deliver. Mr. Trump is thus offering Mr. Putin substantial concessions for an uncertain, potentially negligible reduction in prices.
Would Americans welcome that bargain even if it lowered prices? Would they accept slightly cheaper diesel at the cost of more Ukrainian children killed by Russian missiles? This is not an abstract choice between competing budget priorities. It is about whether an aggressor should receive additional revenue while his missiles continue to strike the country he invaded.
High fuel prices understandably concern Americans, yet public support for Ukraine remains substantial. On Oct. 10, when commentator Michael Smerconish asked his audience whether America should buy Russian diesel if it lowered fuel prices, 95% of more than 62,000 participants said no.
That voluntary poll was not scientifically representative, but a YouGov survey of more than 5,500 adults likewise found more opposition than support for suspending sanctions on Russian diesel.
Mr. Trump invokes American national interests. Yet those interests extend beyond diesel prices to national security, alliances and the containment of aggression. His position contains a striking contradiction. He criticizes Americans for resisting higher fuel prices incurred in confronting Iran’s potential nuclear ambitions, yet apparently considers a smaller price increase unacceptable when confronting Mr. Putin’s Russia — a power that has the world’s largest nuclear arsenal and has repeatedly threatened to use nuclear weapons against the West.
Mr. Trump also criticizes Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for attacking Russian refineries, claiming that these strikes raise diesel prices. Yet stopping them would not necessarily provide Russia with enough diesel for export to affect global prices. Ukrainian attacks reduce fuel available to the Russian military and weaken Moscow’s ability to sustain its invasion.
Here lies a paradox. Mr. Zelenskyy, acting to defend Ukraine, also advances American security interests by weakening a major American adversary. Mr. Trump, claiming to defend those interests, makes concessions that strengthen Mr. Putin.
Mr. Trump’s policy, which promises Americans a small, uncertain economic benefit while providing Russia with substantial strategic advantages, deserves serious scrutiny before it can be called an expression of American national interests.
It is much clearer that Mr. Trump’s concessions serve Mr. Putin’s interests by reducing pressure on his regime and weakening Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.
The slogan “America First” becomes particularly difficult to reconcile with policies that prioritize the interests of a major American adversary waging war in Ukraine and challenging American interests in the Middle East.
The contrast with Mr. Skobov is especially stark. Mr. Skobov risks his freedom and life rather than help Mr. Putin wage war. Mr. Trump weakens pressure on Mr. Putin in pursuit of uncertain economic gains. His remarks amid the escalating attacks on Ukraine compound the moral problem: Mr. Trump said Russia “has been fine on Ukraine” and his envoy, Steve Witkoff, described Mr. Putin as a “humanitarian.”
Yet Mr. Trump’s approach is also difficult to justify strategically. He either excessively fears Mr. Putin or fundamentally misunderstands this war. Contrary to his claims, it is not simply a local European conflict. Russia’s invasion is part of Mr. Putin’s broader confrontation with the free world, especially the U.S. Ukraine’s soldiers defend not only their homeland but also the security of other free nations, including ours.
Mr. Trump repeats his exaggerated claim that America has spent $350 billion supporting Ukraine and complains that the U.S. has received nothing in return. Ukraine, however, has paid a vastly higher price: hundreds of thousands of soldiers killed or wounded while fighting Russian aggression.
The U.S. has already received an enormous strategic return. By resisting Russia and degrading its military capabilities, Ukrainian soldiers have reduced the risk that Americans will one day have to confront an emboldened Russia directly, potentially sacrificing thousands of American lives.
If Mr. Trump fails to recognize that Russia’s war against Ukraine is also a confrontation with the United States, he risks a fundamental strategic mistake. Pressuring Ukraine into capitulation could turn Russia’s aggression into a major defeat for America itself.
Mr. Trump need not choose between American and Ukrainian interests. The countries are allies whose fundamental security interests are closely aligned. He must, however, ensure that his policies serve our country — not those of our principal adversary, Vladimir Putin.
• Yuri Yarim-Agaev is president of the Center for the Study of Totalitarian Ideology and a former Soviet dissident.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.